YACHT CLUB/CLUB LEVEL Review

WDWKOOK

NOW WITH LESS TAG!
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
18,106
The Regatta Club/Club Level
Yacht Club
June 25 - 28, 2014







We recently stayed three nights at the YC-CL. We then moved over to WL-CL for 8 nights. This was our second YC-CL stay and both times we were upgraded. The first time from a Garden View room and this time from a Standard View room. Both times we were upgraded to a Water/Pool View room.

SPOILER ALERT!

Don't bother skipping to the end - I'm going to mention right up front that we don't plan on returning to YC-CL. Our main reasons why we don't plan on returning:

~The Regatta Club lounge: It's too small, too crowded, the TV is often obnoxious and there isn't even a trash can or tray for your dirty dishes and the evening appetizers aren't varied enough. DH likes the new "bartender service," but I prefer the old self-service method.

~We love water views, but dislike pool views. When you book a Water View room at YC, you have a chance of having a SAB/pool view instead which we don't like due to the noise. That's why we have never booked a Water View at YC, but each time we've been upgraded to one.

~The 5th floor rooms are not in acceptable condition and they are long overdo for a rehab.

~The hallways are depressing and dirty.

~The Club Level staff (NOT the lounge staff nor the non-CL CMs) seemed uninspired and most did not make us feel very welcome.

~The Ship Shape Health Club is too small to accommodate guests from two resorts and (at least in the early morning) is very crowded. Cups for water were often depleted and the garbage was over-flowing early morning with dirty cups scattered around the facility.

~Rooftop views: From the hallway windows (that aren't frosted) and from 5th floor rooms.









We arrived by car and we were escorted by a CL Runner up to the 5th floor. DD and DH checked out the lounge while I checked-in. The upgrade was rather unceremonious as I wasn't informed of it. When I was signing my invoice at check-in, I noticed the upgraded room category. I asked the CM if we had been upgraded, but she said she didn't know. I just wanted to make sure there weren't any additional overcharges related to the upgrade and there weren't.

The rest of the check-in was rather slow and mildly contentious. We have close to 15 MBs in our MDX account as Passholders and for 2013-2014 room-only bookings. DH prefers to use a KTTW card, which we know guests can still request. The CL CM was confused about my request for KTTW cards and refused to give me any. She said it wasn't allowed (not true) and she had to ask her manager, who had to then make a call, who then confirmed what I knew and finally gave us KTTW cards. This hasn't been an issue at WL, but was at YC. However, at YC they were able to imprint the KTTW cards with our names, but at WL, the CL no longer has this ability. None of this was a big deal, but wasn't a great way to start our vacation.

Our room wasn't ready, but we had an ADR for Beaches and Cream. Our server was great and the food was tasty. I loved that I could get a fat-free shake which tasted delicious.








We finished our meal and headed to Epcot to use our FP+s. We got the text that the room was ready a few minutes after leaving B&C. We went to our room, 5239, after an afternoon at Epcot.











The view was gorgeous when looking straight out:







When looking down or to the left or right, you saw this:







The room was in need of a deep cleaning. There was an accumulation of dust and dirt on all the baseboards and the bathroom tile and caulking around the toilet was stained. There were also small pieces of debris/garbage on the carpeting and tile.

The iHome clock did not illuminate at all. The dimmer must have broken and stayed stuck in the "off" mode. I reported this to a CL CM our first day, but it was never repaired/replaced. The tall lamp near the bed was barely able to stand upright and looked like it might keel over at any moment.

I had only requested that we not have a connecting door. When the upgrade was confirmed, I asked if the room had a connecting door and was told that it did. I wasn't unappreciative of the upgrade, but we really wanted a room, any room, without a connecting door. I was told that the resort was at 100% occupancy and no rooms without connecting doors were available. Luckily, we didn't hear our neighbors at night/morning, only during the day, so it wasn't a problem.

What was a problem was the amount of garbage and dirty linens that lined the hallway on a daily basis. Whenever we would walk to/from our room, every few doors there would be dirty dishes. While some of the dishes were from room service, most of the dishes were from the lounge. I don't know if housekeeping or guests or both were piling the dishes outside the doors, but they were omnipresent and unavoidable.

Bags of dirty linens, garbage and towels lined the hallways and this is what greeted us everyday outside our room:

 
THE REGATTA CLUB LOUNGE:


The lounge is small and doesn't offer much of a view. There is a small balcony you can go out onto, but the view isn't very interesting and you can't sit out there. Many guests, as evidenced by all the dirty dishes in the hallway, seemed to take back food to their rooms due to lack of seating during busier times such as breakfast and evening appetizers.





























Shortly before our stay, they implemented a new process whereby alcohol is no longer available via self-service:








Our first dinner ADR was at Yachtsman Steakhouse. This was our first visit to YS and it definitely won't be our last. It was our favorite experience and meal of the trip. Our server, Bill, was so friendly, knowledgeable and generous. I can't say enough good things about him. The service, quality and pacing of the meal was perfect. Every single thing was delicious and we plan on dining at YS on future trips. I didn't take many photos and unfortunately, they were taken with my iPhone.



I split the ribeye, twice-baked potato and a caesar salad with DD:








We also ordered truffle mac and cheese and grilled onions:





DH had the ribeye, too, to which Bill generously added the most delicious veal femur marrow. (I promise it tastes much better than it sounds):








MARINA AREA:











 
KOOK,

Our last stay there was also very disappointing. WL CL is our favorite so it kind of spoils it for the rest of the CL's :lmao:
 
I have a lot of respect for you, Kook, which is why I am really paying attention to every bit of your review. :flower3:

I've come to think of rooms in need of a deep clean, and messy hallways as normal at WDW... but it really shouldn't be, especially when prices are so high.
Glad (for others) that YC is getting a refurb soon.

I look forward to reading more of your report.

LOVE the pic of an empty B&C - and of the pool :beach:
 

KOOK,

Our last stay there was also very disappointing. WL CL is our favorite so it kind of spoils it for the rest of the CL's :lmao:
:lmao: That is SO true!!

I have a lot of respect for you, Kook, which is why I am really paying attention to every bit of your review. :flower3:

Me too!!

When Kook talks, people listen...what was that commercial...E.F. Hutton I think :upsidedow

Kook I felt the same way about the CL lounge. DH and I were like "What would we do if we had the kids with us?" Although, the CMs were super nice, they weren't "family" like I felt we had at OFC. We had the fabulous suite with the SAB view (no rooftops from the 4th floor). Thankfully YC rooms are getting the refurb after BC/BCV...sorry the room was less than spectacular :hug:
 
Awesome review as always Kook!

Sorry your stay wasn't up to snuff! :headache:

Somehow, I am sure your subsequent stay at WL might have made up for it? :goodvibes
 
That's too bad. We are returning to the BC CL in Dec after a perfect trip we had in Sept. The CL refurb and rooms should be complete for our stay and I can't wait!! I tried to get WL CL but it's all sold out :(

Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards
 
KOOK,

Our last stay there was also very disappointing. WL CL is our favorite so it kind of spoils it for the rest of the CL's :lmao:
:wave2:


Yep. if you've stayed at WL-CL's 7th floor, then you know that YC doesn't have to be that way.

I have a lot of respect for you, Kook, which is why I am really paying attention to every bit of your review. :flower3:

I've come to think of rooms in need of a deep clean, and messy hallways as normal at WDW... but it really shouldn't be, especially when prices are so high.
Glad (for others) that YC is getting a refurb soon.

I look forward to reading more of your report.

LOVE the pic of an empty B&C - and of the pool :beach:
:wave:

The respect is mutual::yes:: and I agree with you about the messy hallways and need for much better cleaning of Disney rooms, especially in between guests. But, we actually don't feel that way about WL-CL (7th floor), but we have felt that way everywhere else pretty much and even on the 5th floor at WL in a Deluxe CL room:sad2:

When Kook talks, people listen...what was that commercial...E.F. Hutton I think :upsidedow

Kook I felt the same way about the CL lounge. DH and I were like "What would we do if we had the kids with us?" Although, the CMs were super nice, they weren't "family" like I felt we had at OFC. We had the fabulous suite with the SAB view (no rooftops from the 4th floor). Thankfully YC rooms are getting the refurb after BC/BCV...sorry the room was less than spectacular :hug:
:rotfl2: You obviously haven't met my 15-year-old DD:laughing:

I remember your sweet suite "upgrade." Weren't you bumped from RPC? The room rehab at YC is much needed, but will they maintain it? Rooms at WDW can go from new to old in a flash:scared:
 
Awesome review as always Kook!

Sorry your stay wasn't up to snuff! :headache:

Somehow, I am sure your subsequent stay at WL might have made up for it? :goodvibes
Well, there was a good reason the split stay was rather lopsided in favor of WL:thumbsup2

WL-CL remains our favorite CL, however, did you see my Deluxe Room review on the WL thread? You might be surprised.

That's too bad. We are returning to the BC CL in Dec after a perfect trip we had in Sept. The CL refurb and rooms should be complete for our stay and I can't wait!! I tried to get WL CL but it's all sold out :(

Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards
Being in a newly rehabbed room with a rehabbed lounge should be great. Will you be posting a TR?
 
We recently stayed three nights at the YC-CL. We then moved over to WL-CL for 8 nights. This was our second YC-CL stay and both times we were upgraded. The first time from a Garden View room and this time from a Standard View room. Both times we were upgraded to a Water/Pool View room.

SPOILER ALERT!

Don't bother skipping to the end - I'm going to mention right up front that we don't plan on returning to YC-CL. Our main reasons why we don't plan on returning:

~The Regatta Club lounge: It's too small, too crowded, the TV is often obnoxious and there isn't even a trash can or tray for your dirty dishes and the evening appetizers aren't varied enough. DH likes the new "bartender service," but I prefer the old self-service method.

~We love water views, but dislike pool views. When you book a Water View room at YC, you have a chance of having a SAB/pool view instead which we don't like due to the noise. That's why we have never booked a Water View at YC, but each time we've been upgraded to one.

~The 5th floor rooms are not in acceptable condition and they are long overdo for a rehab.

~The hallways are depressing and dirty.

~The Club Level staff (NOT the lounge staff nor the non-CL CMs) seemed uninspired and most did not make us feel very welcome.

~The Ship Shape Health Club is too small to accommodate guests from two resorts and (at least in the early morning) is very crowded. Cups for water were often depleted and the garbage was over-flowing early morning with dirty cups scattered around the facility.

~Rooftop views: From the hallway windows (that aren't frosted) and from 5th floor rooms.

Our first dinner ADR was at Yachtsman Steakhouse. This was our first visit to YS and it definitely won't be our last. It was our favorite experience and meal of the trip. Our server, Bill, was so friendly, knowledgeable and generous. I can't say enough good things about him. The service, quality and pacing of the meal was perfect. Every single thing was delicious and we plan on dining at YS on future trips. I didn't take many photos and unfortunately, they were taken with my iPhone.

Thanks for your detailed (and honest) review. I'm sorry your stay was not a positive one. YC CL used to be on my list of clubs to try, but has been taken off that list for a few reasons (same for BC CL), but mostly due to all of the negative reviews I've read about it the last several months. Having only stayed 3 CLs (with WL CL being one of them), I often wonder how others will compare. Reading reports such as yours has made me rethink the YC, so we will be sticking with the MK area resorts for now ;).

Regarding Yachtsman....I'm glad you had a great experience there. We tried it a few years ago and can't wait to go back. The food was great, the waitstaff was very friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was nice. Glad you will be returning :).

Our last stay there was also very disappointing. WL CL is our favorite so it kind of spoils it for the rest of the CL's :lmao:

I'm sorry you didn't have a pleasant YC CL stay. I totally agree about WL CL as it's hard to beat :thumbsup2.

I have a lot of respect for you, Kook, which is why I am really paying attention to every bit of your review. :flower3:

I've come to think of rooms in need of a deep clean, and messy hallways as normal at WDW... but it really shouldn't be, especially when prices are so high.
Glad (for others) that YC is getting a refurb soon.

I look forward to reading more of your report.

LOVE the pic of an empty B&C - and of the pool :beach:

:thumbsup2


Hi johnsonet :wave:

When Kook talks, people listen...

Kook I felt the same way about the CL lounge. DH and I were like "What would we do if we had the kids with us?" Although, the CMs were super nice, they weren't "family" like I felt we had at OFC. We had the fabulous suite with the SAB view (no rooftops from the 4th floor). Thankfully YC rooms are getting the refurb after BC/BCV...sorry the room was less than spectacular :hug:

Hi pas :wave2:

I agree as she has a lot of good input all the time ::yes::.

WL CL was our first CL stay and we had an amazing time!!! It makes me sad that not all Disney CLs are the same as far as friendly CMs :(.
 
:rotfl2: You obviously haven't met my 15-year-old DD:laughing:

I remember your sweet suite "upgrade." Weren't you bumped from RPC? The room rehab at YC is much needed, but will they maintain it? Rooms at WDW can go from new to old in a flash:scared:

That's the one...YC already had to deal with a disgruntled guest :rotfl: Such a shame for the lack of maintenance...a few cracks and some chipped paint I can deal with...dustbunnies and dirt...not-so-much I get skeeved

And teenagers don't count, they never listen ;) :hug:
 
Hi pas :wave2:

I agree as she has a lot of good input all the time ::yes::.

WL CL was our first CL stay and we had an amazing time!!! It makes me sad that not all Disney CLs are the same as far as friendly CMs :(.

:wave2: I didn't think anyone would surpass GF CMs, and picky DH even got along SO well with the WL CMs :goodvibes (sorry to hijack the YC review Kook)
 
:wave2: I didn't think anyone would surpass GF CMs, and picky DH even got along SO well with the WL CMs :goodvibes (sorry to hijack the YC review Kook)

The WL CMs are amazing (as are the GF CMs :thumbsup2). It's hard to beat those two resorts (IMO) when it comes to club level as well as CMs (just my opinion, of course ;)).

(sorry from me, too, Kook...didn't mean to hijack).
 
Sorry to hear that you had such a terrible experience at the YC. 2 years ago you gave me some great info on WL CL and I have to say that has been my favorite place so far. Last year we stayed at BC CL in a 1 bedroom suite and had an experience very similar to your stay at YC. This year we're staying at the BWI in a deluxe room. This will be our 3rd stay there. I'm hoping the rehab on the deluxe rooms will be complete by the time we get there in 3 weeks. It's too bad that we can't just pick WL up and move it over to the Epcot hotel area!
 
Oh I had hoped it might of gotten better ... Yikes! I had a similar experience with bags of trash in hallways and trays ect. and this was 2 yrs ago. It definitely does not have to be this way and simply sending CM to pick up 3 times a day is a need. We just stayed at an embassy suites and the hallways were picked up several times a day ... At a disney world CL this should be a no brainer to clear the hallways of trash and trays.
The location is fabulous so it's sad
 
KOOK, dd favorite dinner restaurant is the Yachtsman! Food is great and service matches.:goodvibes
 
That's what great about Disney - different resorts for different people.

The one resort I have absolutely NO desire to stay at is WL.

We've gone there for dinner and looked around and it's just eh to me. Add that fact that the rooms are so small makes it easy to avoid staying there.

Now we loved YC and BC CL!

Different strokes for different folks. Sorry you didn't enjoy your YC stay,.
 















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top