WWYD....Graduation question

I'm the last person to want to give gifts to anyone, so the fact that I'm the one here saying gifts is pretty strange! However, I don't think whether my niece or nephews go out of their way to have a relationship with me has anything to do with whether I give gifts for those big occasions (birth, hs graduation, wedding.) I consider those occasions kind of mandatory for minimal gift giving to anyone I want to show interest in. I wouldn't be sending gifts for every occasion, just for those.

My nieces and nephew don't in any way go out of their way to have a relationship with me. My children don't with their aunts and uncles either. I kind of see that as the adult's job I guess.:confused3
 
I’m sending out grad announcements this week (a little late since I graduated on Sunday :rolleyes1:laughing:) and I do NOT expect anything from most of the people on the list. The most I am expecting from some of the people is a phone call or card congratulating me. :cutie:

However, I think it’s a little odd that this relative has no contact with you whatsoever and even seems to avoid you, yet he is sending you an announcement. :confused3 Do whatever you feel comfortable doing. You are under no obligation. You don’t even have to reply. :thumbsup2
 
Are you not invited to parties because they are not having them or they only have friends or is everyone else in the family invited and not you?

We don't send birthday cards to everyone in the family, nor does anyone else. Sometimes we remember to call and sometimes they do too. In other words, we don't get worked up about "family" birthday parties. The kids have parties with friends, not all the relatives.

We DO, however, get together to celebrate big things like Bar/Bat Mitzvah (my SIL's family), graduations, etc. No one would think twice about not getting a birthday card yet receiving a graduation announcement. We do get together for Christmas and 4th of July, the rest of the holidays are hit or miss because everyone is married and have obligations to those families as well. When we get together everyone has a blast, the kids LOVE playing together and it is a good time.
 
*bolding mine*

I don't know what happened and have never asked. I agree, however this graduate goes next door to my sisters house but never stops by and says "Hey" to us, even if we are outside.

Edit...Actually not true, when selling fundraisers he would come by.

Thanks for your replies! :)

Do you go over to see him when he's there?
 

18 year old boy? Send him a gift certificate to any place that sells food... awesome. Even $10 was amazing when I graduated.
 
Take if for what it is, an announcement telling you he has graduated. If you feel compelled to send a gift or card, send one, if not just ignore it.

I never knew until the DIS how much time and effort people took in things they receive. If I want to go, I go, if not I refuse. If I want to send a card or gift I send one. I don't think I have ever put that much thought into the motives of an invitation or announcement! I guess I am the weird person that doesn't realize everyone is talking about her behind her back!! I guess the old saying is true, ignorance is bliss!
 
Take if for what it is, an announcement telling you he has graduated. If you feel compelled to send a gift or card, send one, if not just ignore it.

I never knew until the DIS how much time and effort people took in things they receive. If I want to go, I go, if not I refuse. If I want to send a card or gift I send one. I don't think I have ever put that much thought into the motives of an invitation or announcement! I guess I am the weird person that doesn't realize everyone is talking about her behind her back!! I guess the old saying is true, ignorance is bliss!

Don't worry Powerrj, I'm there with you.

On the relationship note, I do have some food for thought. I have a sister who moved half way across the country at 19 and eloped and had a family. As her sons grew toward adulthood they seemed to want little to do with their relatives. As the oldest went out on his own and married and had his own family, he decided to make the attempt to form relationships with us and get to know us. What I learned from talking to him is that his mother had bad feelings toward us all for not spending our vacations visiting her and other slights. He and his brother were raised their whole lives hearing her perspectives on why we were so awful and they, being kids who only heard one side, bought into it. They always felt unloved because they didn't get a card on their birthday and nobody visited, and so on. (Keep in mind the mail works both ways and nobody up here got cards or acknowledgements for anything). Once he got to know us through an adults eyes he realized we were all just busy trying to lead our own lives and we never meant to slight anyone. My point on this is your nephew is still under the influence of his parents and who knows what he hears at home that is impacting his relationship with you.

If you are truly interested in having a relationship with him you could skip the check / gift and instead offer to take him out to dinner to celebrate. That would be a kind gesture and it would give him a chance to decide on his own whether he wants to spend some time getting to know you.
 
I'd send a card and leave it at that. No money from me.
 
*bolding mine*

I don't know what happened and have never asked. I agree, however this graduate goes next door to my sisters house but never stops by and says "Hey" to us, even if we are outside.

Edit...Actually not true, when selling fundraisers he would come by.

Thanks for your replies! :)

Lets face it, you recieved this notice in the hopes that you will send a check. I would telephone him and wish him well! and be done with it!
 
Is he your relative on your side or your husbands?

I would send a $25 giftcard to someplace in the area that sells dorm stuff if he is going to college. Otherwise a $25 check.

It's not a child's decision which adults and relatives get invited to their parties, etc., the issue is between you and your IL's or sibling. Whether or not he is a teenager, you are still the adult and if you see him you should be approaching him to say hi when you see him from your sister's house next door.
 
Uhm, given what you've said in your post? No, nothing. Nephew would get zip zero zilch.
 
I don't think a gift is mandatory. But I do like what chloelovesdisney said. $25 seems reasonable.

I was just thinking that when I graduated, I remember sending out announcements to relatives because I was proud of myself. I didn't even expect to get gifts. I just wanted to share the news and send a picture. I guess kids are different now, though.
 
It's unfortunate that announcements are seen as asking for a gift. My son only sent to immediate family. I would have liked to have sent them to more people because I wanted them to know about it, but I was afraid that it would be asking for a gift which we don't expect. I guess when I send Christmas cards this year I might write one of those braggy how wonderful my kids are letters enclosed instead!:rotfl2:
 
It's unfortunate that announcements are seen as asking for a gift. My son only sent to immediate family. I would have liked to have sent them to more people because I wanted them to know about it, but I was afraid that it would be asking for a gift which we don't expect. I guess when I send Christmas cards this year I might write one of those braggy how wonderful my kids are letters enclosed instead!:rotfl2:


As one who said this announcement was asking for a gift, I'd like to clarify (because I definitely don't want people thinking I mean all announcements) that 99.9% of announcements are not gift grabs. They are just what they are supposed to be: a way to announce life altering news that you feel your family and friends might find interesting. Whether it's a birth announcement, marriage announcement, graduation announcement or any other kind, I am sure that almost all of them are sent with only the very best intentions. However, this particular case involves someone who apparently doesn't say one word to these particular extended family members when he's walking past them. In that case, it seems strange that he doesn't think they'd like to hear any of his news in person (or even hear the word "Hello", apparently!) but he does think they want to hear about his graduation. I, personally, think it isn't appropriate to send someone a graduation (or any other) announcement unless you are close enough to them (relationship-wise) that you would tell them the news in person if you happened to be walking within shouting distance of them. That doesn't mean I think you should intentionally go visit them to tell them, but if you are already near enough to speak to them and you never do, I think that says a lot about your relationship (or lack thereof). In this specific case, I believe he sent the announcement in the hopes of receiving gifts.

I'm sure that those on this thread who sent announcements did not do so as gift grabs. I sent out annoucements when I graduated, even to family members I very rarely communicate with. But I didn't send them to anyone who I wouldn't speak to if I was walking past them, because I think it would be ridiculous to do that.

It bothers me that so many people seem to be ignoring the specifics of this case and jumping to the conclusion that anyone who thinks this announcement was a gift grab is implying that all announcements are gift grabs, when (for me, at least) that is simply not the case.
 
If you went to a party for him, you'd be obliged to give a gift. But I don't think so for just an announcement. If you want to, you can send him a card. :)

If a kid were constantly passing my home without stopping by to say hello sometimes, I wouldn't feel close enough to him to give a gift unless we were invited to a party for him.
 
You are absolutely not obligated to send a gift. I personally would probably send a card with a nice note written in it. I wouldn't send a gift, mainly because the sending of the announcement strikes me as a blatant gift grab and I never want to reward that sort of thing.
While I disagree with the blatant gift grab thing, I absolutely agree with sending a congratulatory card.

Announcements are just that: an announcement. A graduation, a birth, a wedding, etc. I receive written announcements in the same way I receive spoken announcements - I reply in kind: "Congratulations! How wonderful! I'm so happy for you!" If I receive an invitation to celebrate the event that was announced, then I consider getting or sending a gift.

Of course, if it's an immediate family member or friend whom I interact with on a regular basis, then I might consider getting a gift because, after all, I love them and want to celebrate the occassion. But it's not something I feel obligated to do; I do it because I want to.
 
Send a card and write in it..."I'll give you your gift next time I see you." Then wait and see how long it is before he shows up at your house. :rotfl:
 
Well, I don't have any nieces and nephews that I don't see; but we still get graduation announcements for kids we had in child care. Some we have sort of kept up with and stayed friendly with the parents, some we have not seen nor heard from since they started Kindergarten. We have gotten a few we don't even remember and then when we do realize its a kid we only kept for a short time. :rotfl:

It just depends on the way we feel about it as to whether we send something. And you should do the same, OP. If you feel that you need to send a card do so, if you feel pulled to send something small, do so. Some of the things we have done are small gift cards for fast food, movie gift cards, or if we know the kid is going to college and where we will get a small gift card from the school's book store (if they have them). We don't spend more than $20 (some years we would go bankrupt if we did more!!).
 
Send a card and write in it..."I'll give you your gift next time I see you." Then wait and see how long it is before he shows up at your house. :rotfl:

:lmao::thumbsup2



UPDATE....

This weekend while camping, I was talking to my brother (not the father of the grad) and he started talking casually about something that happened at said Grad's graduation party...so yep, there was a party. Which reminded me of this thread....so, I thought I would update...not that anyone really cares but here goes anyway!! :laughing:


I sent him $20 in a card, three weeks ago. I have not heard a single word from him. :rolleyes1

I know some people said it was a problem between the adults but I consider him an adult, he is 18 and he should have at least said thank you. Honestly though I didn't think we would. I am now done with gifts for him, period.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom