I am so happy for you. It's that kind of unpredictable pixie dust that makes WDW so magical. I don't think the CM set a precedent to comp meals at VA; instead the CM continued the WDW tradition of surprising/ magically recovering the experience of an unhappy guest. I think it is wonderful that cast members are empowered to make choices, present surprises, and positively change the individual experiences of a guest (even if they sometimes first need to check availability/feasability). To the OP, have a wonderful 25th anniversary dinner.