Would you pull a first grader out of school??

I just wanted to add a little different perspective: My DH is in the AF and we live in Germany. In Dec (10 Dec- 6 Jan) we will be returning home to Fl, with 10 days spent at WDW. My daughter will be in 3rd grade this year and will miss 2weeks of school because of this trip. I will encourage her teacher to send any school work she wants her to complete with us, none of her other teachers have ever taken us up on it and none of our family vacations have ever impacted DD's education. For DOD schools family vacations are a way of life and it is perfectly acceptable for both students and teacher.
 
I am a teacher of physics and chemistry in high school. With this is mind, take your kids to Disney. The two most important aspects of student achievement are (1) Effective Teachers and then right behind it is (2) Parental Influence. I guarentee that the kids will remember Disney much more than they remember what they did in school that week. Also, the trip will probably strengthen the bond between child and parent, especially for older kids as well, and that will help the educational process for that student. Go and enjoy it.
I would recommend, especially in the high school, to inform the school about 2 months ahead of time, when you can, and let them know. Talk to each teacher personally and let them know as well. Then make sure that your child knows the importance of staying on task and getting make-up work done BEFORE he leaves. That way, on the trip, he has everything done and will be on track when he gets back.
 
We just booked a trip to WDW for Jan. 2005 and our DS 3rd grader, and DS 1st grader will miss a week of school.

This is the first time we are pulling them out of school for vacation and we were feeling a bit guilty about it at first. But it is great to see that at least on this thread we are not the only ones.

This is also our first time going to WDW in January...usually we travel in HOT June!!!

The things we do to see a mouse :earsboy: ;)
 
So far, my daughter has missed a week of kindergarten, third grade and this fall she'll miss a week of fourth grade. My son missed a week of first grade and will miss a week of second. I'm at the school volunteering all the time, and when you see how little time they actually spend "on task" and how much time they spend waiting for other kids to do stuff or get to a certain place, or eat lunch or have recess, the instructional time AT the school is really not that much (at the elementary level). Sure, they're learning patience and following instructions and such, but our teachers have very nicely prepared my children's work for them to bring along.

We were leaving on a Sunday, so my third-grader literally sat down and knocked out a week's worth of work Friday afternoon. My first-grader did some at home and brought some along. They both got A's on their tests when they got home.

Since we live in reasonable driving distance from Orlando, I think the teachers have sort of resigned themselves to mid-school vacations.

I think you can emphasize the importance of education in your family, and your kids will realize that school isn't the only place they should be prepared to learn something. Use the family time as an opportunity to show how much YOU are still learning -- your trip can be a seminar to teach your family about "lifetime learning" (which is a big buzzword around here).

Take a deep breath and remember, even at school, you are the customer!
 

Go For It!

We plan to take DD in December 2005. She will be in kindergarten and will miss 9 school days. I am a low senority nurse, so I can't get my vacations during the school breaks. I wish I could.
 
Warning! This is a touchy subject and I am climbing on my soapbox. I have never minded having the kids miss school within reason, but you have to be careful with your district's policy. When I took my kids out in elementary grades (it was my brother's wedding in LA so he picked the date!) the teachers told me they don't assign work ahead of time because they don't know where the class will be at a date in the future. It would be too much work for them to custom plan work for traveling kids (mine or anyone's). We went anyway - after all if we were flying all the way from MA to CA for a wedding how could we not stay a little longer to see Disneyland, San Diego, and a quick drive over the border into Mexico? DD won our town's 4th grade spelling bee but she never talks about that but she can go on and on about our trip to Disneyland. Two years ago we spent 10 days in DisneyWorld in October. Now they were high school and middle schoolers. On parents night in September I warned every single teacher, offered for the kids to do any work ahead of time, offered to bring textbooks with us, offered to have classmates keep track of missed notes, etc. Every single teacher said go, relax, enjoy, don't worry about it. Then when we got back they didn't let the kids make up tests they had missed or homework assignments. Even with all those zeros they still did OK for the year. In our district there is no such thing as an excused absence so if you are in the hospital for a week tough luck. With all that said I still make the decisions on what is best for my family and we are going again in October (but only for a week that includes Columbus Day ) and DS is in college now. I find the professors are much more understanding of the fact that sometimes peoples real lives don't match a school schedule exactly. Whew... sorry, Valerie
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom