I like to be able to talk to people and change things if the price goes down
So choose a TA with a phone number. DU doesn't have that up front. I like costcotravel.com. They aren't 24/7 but they are easy to get ahold of. I book online then call them if I feel like it. And I like booking online. I don't like the quote nonsense. I want to BOOK the thing.
it drove me crazy having to call every time I wanted to change anything.
What did you change that required calling every time.
When we've booked with a TA for both Royal and Disney, we have to call to...change cabins. Pay in full required a phone call with our first TA, but with costco it's all through their website.
Tangent: If I successfully transfer my cruise to Costco, how much control do I actually lose?
Things I want to be able to do:
Get early PAT
Get as many Palo bookings as possible
Try to snag Rainforest Day pass
Request to dine alone if possible
...that's about it. Oh and I want to buy my own cruise insurance.
All of those things can be done directly. Even the dining request. If you call and say "I booked through a TA and need to..." they'll stop you and say "go through your TA". If you say "this is what I want to do" and then they get into your account, in 100% of my own experiences they don't need to talk to a TA for requests.
As others have said, the day pass is a link online. You can also call and purchase it. EASY. Palo is done on your own, PAT is done on your own.
Buying cruise insurance is easy. Though Costco's insurance is good, you should get a quote from them (they'll send you to their insurance people, it's not done BY them) to compare to the other companies you're thinking of using.
thanks everyone. I am seriously considering it....Sounds crazy cause....here I am. But I hate internet and I like the actual contact with a person on the phone when doing business. Probably the only person who dosen't pay bills online.

Kerri
So, again, choose a company you can call. Costco is one of them.
Also, are all these OBC offers still good if I'm booking for 2016?
Daisyx3
You'd have to look at the specifics of their offerings. I considered using DU once and among the reasons I didn't (utter lack of contacting me back was the ultimate reason) was that they didn't have OBC for the timeframe of my cruise. Costco did. End of story.