Would this spoil the Magic?

heffalump9

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 15, 2003
Messages
538
The past two years my DH and I have gotten great deals at AKL and really loved staying there. This year I want to make a short Disney visit (solo trip) in 03/2004 to be with friends who will be at Disney from Alaska. Since most of my time will be spent with my friends and at the parks, would the ASMv be a good choice or is it difficult to stay at a Value once you have experienced the Deluxes? I could look into non- Disney hotels but I love being in the middle of the Magic and Disney transporation is a big plus!

Help! All suggestions will be welcomed!
 
It isn't going to SPOIL the magic, but you may be spoiled by AKL. I am having the same issue. I have been to WL and am going to try PC. I really fear a value and really want AKL or WL. I can afford it, but can't justify it.....so we are trying PC unless some great room rates come out before our trip, then I will switch to AKL or WL.

:Pinkbounc Bouncing in anticipation for room only rates!:Pinkbounc

You will enjoy your trip because it is Disney. If you will be enjoying the parks a lot, you should be just fine.

We, on the other hand, are only doing 4 day hoppers on an 8 day stay. It makes me nervous.

Good Luck!
 
Our first stay on disney property was at AKL. The lobby was so impressive. Everything was beautiful. For our next trip, we stayed st All Star Sports. I have to admit that when we walked into the lobby, I was incredibly disappointed. The room--it was neat and clean. No real complaints. That initial disappointment was pretty much momentary. We returned for a second time to Sports. And have since stayed at Music. This December, we are at Movies. Granted, the all stars lack the "deluxe" nature and feel of the AKL, but they have a very playful, happy atmosphere. You will have a fine time. Expect it to be different, but don't worry about the magic. It will still be there.
 
As long as you know ahead of time that the lobby and amenities will not be nearly as spectacular then yes it can be magical. It feels like you are in a cartoon Disney World full of giant characters, colors and fun lighting at night. The room is comfortable and upbeat. I suggest requesting a top floor. I have stayed at many of the deluxes and all of the moderates and wouldn't hesitate to recommend a stay (at least once) at the All Star. Prep your mind ahead and have a great time.
 

Most of the magic is the company you keep!

All Stars were excellent when I stayed there in the mid-late 90's. Personally, any time I can go on site to vacation and not have to worry about driving and have access to all parks and other sites, I'm in heaven.

You will be, too. Enjoy...
 
Spend the extra money. If you don't you will be very disappointed. Considering, it's really not that much difference in price. Save on other items.
 
We were having the same problem. We've always stayed at deluxes, but when I went to make reservations that all changed.

They wanted overe $200 a night at WL and AKL so I checked the new PC. We were able to get a rate of $68. That's close to $150 a night savings. After hearing that, the decision was a lot easier. By staying at PC we would be saving over $1,500.

Don't try to compair the two. Ones a budget and ones a deluxe.

If your like us we don't spend a whole lot of time at the hotel except to sleep. Hopefully it works, because if it does we won't go back to the deluxes, even though we love the WL.

Boy I'm getting cheap in my old age. pirate:
 
I've stayed in deluxe, moderate and value resorts based on the rates I could get and what my budget was for that trip. My feeling is always: I'm at Disney World! Magic! One year I was at the Yacht Club in Jan., All Star Music in May, and POR in October and I had a wonderful, magical trip each time. Go with the budget you are comfortable with, keep the magic in your heart and you will have a great trip!
 
I don't think it will spoil the magic if you don't have big expectations.

You are well informed and know the realistic differences between the two properties... I think you can have fun anywhere.

Cass...
 
Our first trip we stayed at ASMu and had a great time. Since then we've stayed at many of the deluxes. Last year, I took a friend to WDW and she and I stayed at ASMu for budget purposes. Since it was a short trip with most of our time spent in the parks, it was perfect for us. I didn't miss the deluxe stay at all (other than the long walk to our room in Country Faire). -HM
 
The bottom line is you will be with friends and in WDW. take time to take them over to W, their being from Alaska would be a treat for them and you could get a temporary "fix". LOL
 
Originally posted by heffalump9
The past two years my DH and I have gotten great deals at AKL and really loved staying there. This year I want to make a short Disney visit (solo trip) in 03/2004 to be with friends who will be at Disney from Alaska. Since most of my time will be spent with my friends and at the parks, would the ASMv be a good choice or is it difficult to stay at a Value once you have experienced the Deluxes? I could look into non- Disney hotels but I love being in the middle of the Magic and Disney transporation is a big plus!

I had the same situation when my mother came down to visit me two years ago. In the past, when my father was able to join her, they've stayed at the Contemporary, Polynesian, and more recently, the Grand Floridian. The latter of the three really spoiled them. :)

I wanted to have my mother stay at AK Lodge when she came down to visit, but since she was solo, she didn't see the need to spend so much money. She stayed at All Star Music. She enjoyed it just as much as any other hotel, especially the monetary savings.

I think as long as you realize that a Value resort will not have all the amenities of a Deluxe, then you'll be all set. Just think of all the money you'll be saving! :)
 
Have you considered a moderate?? The All Stars are just a bit noisy for me, and I love the slower quieter atmospheres at POR and CSR. They aren't much more.
 
We started all of our stays being deluxe hotels and then went down to the moderates. My sife being aresort snob said no way on All-stars until lat year. Now that is all she wants us to book unless the rates are too good to pass up at the others.

I would not worry about losing the magic. I know my son thinks the AllStar resorts are great right up there with AKL

:bounce: :tongue: :Pinkbounc
 
What's really hard is spending 5 nights in a 2 br, preferably at old key west, and THEN going down to an all star resort for the weekend (dvc points higher on weekend). It's still disney though and we spend LESS time in the room on those days and more time in the room on our OKW days.
 
The differences between the rooms in the price categories are significant. Disney provides an on-line view of the floor plan of the resort rooms on its Official web site. Explore these plans and note all the differences.

Note the privacy of the vanity areas. In the budget and moderate rooms, the bathroom sink is not enclosed and in full view of the entire room (and outside the room if the curtains are open).

Note the space granted to the toilet-shower areas. If one is sitting on the "throne", does the door swing collide with one's knees? Privacy and space is magic. Less privacy and space is less magic.

Note the amount of furniture provided in the room. The more horizontal space the more the magic.

Note the closet space. Is there a door to the closet? How much clutter will one's luggage and purchases need to occupy.

One little insight about the beds at the Port Orleans resorts. The mattress frame is wooden and stick out much too far from the edge of the mattresses. This means one's foot tends to slam into the protruded bed frame corners painfully and often. We had to re-arrange furniture (tables and chairs) so as to protect the tempation to step too near the corners of the bed. This ill-planned furnishing definitely removed some of the magic for us.

Nothing can compare to the pleasure and comfort of a stay in the delux rooms. We have stayed at the Contemporary twice and the Polynesian Resort this past September. The amount spent on the rooms were well worth it even for the little time spent during the day at the resorts.

Remember this. The time during which you will want to be most pampered so as to feel that a vacation is pleasant, memorable and magic will be at NIGHT when you retire and then again in the morning when you are most in need of a good night's rest on a big comfy bed in a room that is most likely to grant you the most amount of sleep. You will want good options for quick and easy morning grooming needs, access to a variety of breakfast options and minimum wait time for transport to the parks and back. Nothing meets all these desirables than the Delux resort especially the monorail resorts.

You get what you pay for.
 
I've done both, and have no problem going back to the Mods or even the all stars. I just want to be at DW.
 
Let me start by saying, my wife and I have gone (as adults) to Disney World three times: '96 at Port Orleans, '00 at Dixie Landings, and '02 at Caribbean Beach.

Our next trip, sadly not until in '05 (hey, we're dealing with the birth of two kids over the past three years!), we plan on splitting our stay - going to the All Star and then Wilderness Lodge.

We we want to try each of the resorts (if possible). If you stay at the All Stars, just look at it as a new experience in Disney Magic.
 
Originally posted by kirby428
The differences between the rooms in the price categories are significant. Disney provides an on-line view of the floor plan of the resort rooms on its Official web site. Explore these plans and note all the differences.

Note the privacy of the vanity areas. In the budget and moderate rooms, the bathroom sink is not enclosed and in full view of the entire room (and outside the room if the curtains are open).

Note the space granted to the toilet-shower areas. If one is sitting on the "throne", does the door swing collide with one's knees? Privacy and space is magic. Less privacy and space is less magic.

Note the amount of furniture provided in the room. The more horizontal space the more the magic.

Note the closet space. Is there a door to the closet? How much clutter will one's luggage and purchases need to occupy.

One little insight about the beds at the Port Orleans resorts. The mattress frame is wooden and stick out much too far from the edge of the mattresses. This means one's foot tends to slam into the protruded bed frame corners painfully and often. We had to re-arrange furniture (tables and chairs) so as to protect the tempation to step too near the corners of the bed. This ill-planned furnishing definitely removed some of the magic for us.

Nothing can compare to the pleasure and comfort of a stay in the delux rooms. We have stayed at the Contemporary twice and the Polynesian Resort this past September. The amount spent on the rooms were well worth it even for the little time spent during the day at the resorts.

Remember this. The time during which you will want to be most pampered so as to feel that a vacation is pleasant, memorable and magic will be at NIGHT when you retire and then again in the morning when you are most in need of a good night's rest on a big comfy bed in a room that is most likely to grant you the most amount of sleep. You will want good options for quick and easy morning grooming needs, access to a variety of breakfast options and minimum wait time for transport to the parks and back. Nothing meets all these desirables than the Delux resort especially the monorail resorts.

[h1]You get what you pay for. [/h1]


Yes, these may be improvements to all, but lets look at the math for my upcoming vacation to WDW.

I will be staying 19 nights at the, should I stay it, All-star Music and Movies. The first part of the vacation will be on AP rates, the last will be on the Come Back Offer.

When pricing out this vacation I checked at our beloved AKL and other properties, but eliminated the rest as if we want to upgrade to a Deluxe AKL is our main choice.

The best room rate I could get at AKL at the time was $189 for Savannah (gotta see the animals from teh room). Now I see where I could get the rook at AP for $149. So, I will use that price.

$149 x 1.115 (tax) = $166.13 per night (give a few cents incase I go the wrong tax level)

19 x 166.13 = 3156.47 for the AKL Room

My All-Star rooms are:
AP rate 54.82 tax included for 6 nights = 328.92
Come Back Offer $51.47 for 13 nights = 669.11

GRAND TOTAL - 998.03

Difference: 2158.44 Savings

During my vacation I have Priority seatings for most of the better restaurants, 2 wine pairing , 1 wine school and other wine fest features, Illumination cruise, CRT. Will be renting a pontoon for a few hours. And with all this we still haven't come close to spending the $2100 we saved on the room.

We will be going back to WDW in January and use what is left as the starting point of this vacation. Yes you do get what you pay for, but for me - I'd much rather have a decent clean hotel at a great price and be able to stay for twice as long and then get another vacation to boot for the same amount of money. Give me 30 days of vacation over a little luxary any day.

Now, if I can get a $109 rate again for AKL I will spend a few days there as my son loves "his" animals, but we learned as past resort snobs all levels of resorts offer Disney Magic and fun. The people who are around you make the most magic and pixie dust.

Just another point of view.



:hyper: :sunny: :hyper:

:Pinkbounc :bounce:
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom