We at at Puck's express 3x last trip, once in the west side area and twice in the marketplace area and LOVED it. IMHO its a great value for an excellent meal and our server 2 of the 3 times was terrific.
The mac & cheese at the one in the west side is addictive
I haven't done the sit down restaurant but its high on the list for next time.
Ate at Captain Jacks on a prior trip and it was good but nothing to rave about.
We LOVE Wolfgang's - we've eaten there every time we've been at Disney (okay, not every time, just the recent 4 trips) and it's never been anything but great. Good food, good service, just GOOD!
Capt. Jacks was AWFUL in February. Service was good. Our clam chowder didn't have one clam in it and the other food was not great. I have not eaten at Wolf Gang Puck but would like to try it.
We ate at WPC and Captain Jack's on our last trip. We much preferred Wolfgang. We have plans to go back to WPC on our next trip and we have no plans for Captain Jack's.
We felt the same way! The food wasn't horrible...but it wasn't good enough to bring us back again either. IMO there's better choices at DD, Wolfgangs being one of them.