Wish or Magic-4 night Cruise to Bahamas?

[Cfabar1]

we have done the wish twice, and for that reason are trying the Magic this fall. PC is much easier for us to get to, but we wanted to try the Magic so we will deal with getting to PE...

After this trip though, we are likely to stick with PC for all cruising, unless it is an Alaska or something like that...

 

[Jdismom]

We were just on the Magic with a 3 and 5 year old and it was definitely a great choice with young children! That ship is much easier to get around, and you will have a third of the people on the private island with you than you would with the Wish. Makes for a much more enjoyable experience.