How *not* to try and wash your resale points - autobiographical:
After many weeks of spreadsheeting my
DVC math I finally just signed off on a shiny new 150-pt CCV contract with an effective rate of $205/pt down from $255/pt ($26/pt discount maxed out at 150 pts + $20/pt Magical Beginnings + $4/pt Disney Premier Visa). Hooray! But the end was much different that I had planned when I couldn't bring myself to do what would have made sense.
TLDR: Meme below explains - Bought Direct while keeping Resale that would have been washed.
I had awaited the chance to wash our CCV resale into direct points for future-proofing so this was immediately of interest. The timing wasn't perfect for the CCV incentives sale (we have an Oct UY), but I figured these would be few and far between so gotta do it now. We have 3x resale contracts at CCV: 100pt, 125pt, and 125pt.
I crunched a bunch numbers and finally narrowed on either 200 pts direct and selling the 100 pt resale, or 150 pts and selling the 100 pt resale.
I briefly looked at doing a full bore approach of 400 direct and sell off the whole 350, but the upfront cash cost on 400 CCV was close to $95K then we'd have to wait for the resales to close and pay off a big chunk of that. Nope, nope, nope.
Buying 200 direct and selling 100 resale would have been a net cost of around $30K and 100 net positive points. Buying 150 direct and selling 100 resale would be around $19K but only net positive 50 pts.
But wait, what if I bought the 150 direct and sold off nothing! Cost would be around $32K, just about $2K more to gain 150 pts instead of netting 100 new CCV points in the other scenario.
Why I decided against washing points and instead keeping the resale CCV stack was those resale purchases were intended as my Cabin points. I intended to use those resale points at CCV and keeping the 350 resale there would cover our annual 3-4 night stays in a Cabin for our time of year visits. Why would I spend $$$ to wash points that I was still going to continue to use at CCV.
Also part of the problem was our resale contracts had just received their Oct UY 25 pts and I had already earmarked those points for our 2026 winter Cabin stay. So if I sold the loaded contract *and* did Magical Beginnings then I'd lose both sets of '25 UY points.
I initially thought (wrongly so) that I could transfer points from one contract to another to strip my '25 UY pts off the 100-pt resale contract before listing it. Nope, that was a mistake on my part. You can transfer between two of your own memberships, but not within one membership's contracts (we only have one UY/membership). So to still use our resale current UY pts I would have to hold the contract(s) until after our December 2026 Cabin visit. That's a long time to wait to sell the resale contracts if it was part of my math for offsetting the cost of the larger direct points purchase.
A nice bonus is now having another resort with a blue-card-proof 150 pts also gives us future flexibility. Say in 10-20 years we don't need the big 2-bd stays when our traveling party is smaller and want to offload some points but keep our APs (hopefully that perk remains!), then we'd have to keep VGF no matter what. It also lets us one day maybe transfer a blue card contract to one of our kids (maybe to both, if the future surprises us).
CCV is not a resale-restricted resort which is another bonus. If we love LSL we can use these direct points there or at BCV2 in 20 years. Who knows. Meanwhile, I'll keep our resale Cabin points for CCV use.
Final bonus: Welcome to the DVC Comma Club!
