mittelst,
Glad to have you posting here, thanks for sharing your views, I agree with many of them. We are Vero beach owners, along with BCV, we like offsite vacations in addition to onsite.
You'll find some offsite resort bashing by a small minority of posters, but if you aren't familiar with some of thier past negative posting history, you may give that small minority's views more credibility or attention than they really deserve. Your point about trading and the high point cost for Concierge Collection are good ones, and help make a case for more offsite locations and DVC alternatives other than those directly in WDW. I agree with you and hope to see more offsite successes like the successes I see in Hilton Head and Vero Beach resorts where it is becoming increasingly hard to get reservations without the 11 month window, and both resorts almost sold out, if not already. The resonable point value for DVC resorts certainly makes them more desirable than trading out. We don't happen to, but you may be surprised at how many DVC owners also own another type of timeshare for thier offsite vacations. I'd prefer additional DVC locations myself.
Hope to see you continuing to post here in the future. This is a great place to get good information about DVC.