I'll be perfectly honest: some of my reasons are a result of hearing trip reports from friends/families and from reading them on places like cruise critic. I know people should form their own opinions, but in this case it could be an expensive way to find out negative issues are right. We just don't get to vacation enough to want to take as many chances.
So onward we go:
1) I just like Disney
2) CASTAWAY CAY
3) Though we are two adults, no kids, we aren't party people other than a few drinks. I like the family oriented atmosphere you find on DCL. Oddly enough, apart from the occasional shrieking, it's pretty peaceful.
4) Addendum to #3 -- the stories I've heard from people I know as well as reviewers reflect a more adult/party atmosphere on other cruise ships. I like that even the adult venues on DCL are very tame.
5) We sail 4-nighters, and on other cruise lines, the shorter cruises are typically done on older, more run-down ships...and addendum again, tend to have a reputation for the wilder crowd. I like that on DCL you could expect the same ship and service quality on the Wonder as on the Magic.
6) I've also heard a lot of stories about other cruise lines being less strict about keeping children out of the adult pool areas. I haven't yet run across a child in the adult pool or Serenity Beach. Have heard similar things about enforcing smoking areas as well.
7) Majority of people sailing on DCL are sailing with children -- which means the adult-only sections always seem to be used less (at least in comparison to the family areas...wow those pictures we have of CC family beach
)
8) Amazing, personal, friendly service.
9) I haven't had another cruise line offer anything different enough to make me think I just HAVE to try them out. Could care less about flow riders, ice skating, restaurants you pay for (well, that number of them anyway, perfectly happy just having the one...or maybe two on the Dream
). Although I do wish DCL would try that anytime dining.
10) Larger staterooms
11) Easy-peasy embark/disembark
12) Had to edit to add: FIREWORKS at sea! Love that!
Again, I know for everyone that complains about these other cruise ships, there is someone who will post on here that they never saw any of that. And I believe they did experience it like they say as well. But I can't dismiss the opinions of people I know and respect, and besides...it's harder to convince yourself to go another way line when you know that while you
might be happy on a different cruise line, you know from experience you'll almost certainly be happy on DCL.