I do indeed remember the castle as the cake. I was emotionally distraught the entire time we were in the Magic Kingdom. I eventually got over it on subsequent trips, when the castle was back to normal. Then last year we got the opportunity to go to California for my partner's brother's wedding.
Disneyland at last, I was excite and happy. Well, the wedding was in August of 2004. Our trip was planned so I do some last minute internet searches on DL, and discover the horrible, sickening news. The castle I had dreamed of seeing since I was a mere lad, would be covered by a big blue tarp while we were there. I was emotinally distraught even before we left for CA. I cried to my friend, she thought I was crazy. I told her of the birthday cake castle nightmare. Needless to say, once I was in the Magic Kingdom at DL, I stood infront of the "Magical Blue Tarp" as i called it that trip and smiled. I returned home and photoshopped a photo of the castle into the picture. I am a little worried about Cinderella Castle when we go to WDW in June of this year. But as long as it isn't pink, I think I will be ok.
Here are the before and after pics:
http://tinypic.com/1i1guc
PS: This is my first post!