Who is ready for american idol tonight??

[Flyfly_Eclipse]

I'm hoping Diana and George do very well! They are two of my favorites. I am not a fan of John Stevens, but I hope he does pretty well

 

[nana2tots]

Well for weeks i have said Camille has to go, so we'll see!!!!!!!!heck my dog sings better than her, at least she smiles when she barks, LOL disneykid

 

[UncleKyle]

I thought Camile should have been the first one gone. John Stevens at least had some good performances a week or two ago. She's been aweful all along. I'm rooting for George, Diana, and Jasmine.

 

[grinningghost]

Just wondering what it takes to get through to vote. I tried and tried last week and kept getting a busy signal. I really wanted to vote for John Stevens. I felt he deserved another week. Motown is an African-American genre and of course, those were the singers that did great last week.

Not to turn it into a racial thing, in case that's what you're thinking. If JS doesn't get in, I'd like to see George take it all. He's just so lovable - in a goofy way.

 

[RayJay]

OK no way Jasmine was just Average compared to Jon Peter Lewis - he was awful tonight. And John Stevens was no better.

Jasmine is the best so far.

RayJay

 

[palmtreegirl]

Oh my John Stevens was really terrible. I can sing better then that and I can't sing.

JPL wasn't much better and I'm with Simon in regards to Fantasia, she did nothing for me.

Last years group was much better at this point, these kids just seem to be going down hill.

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

I agree Ray Jay, tonight they have all stunk....well Jasmine was not too bad.

I love Jasmine and I hope she makes it through.

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

Camille HAS to go!!

Yay for George, I like him more and more each week. He did good tonight!!!!

 

[snoopy]

George is so talented, I hope he takes the whole thing.

 

[palmtreegirl]

Yikes Camille was really bad.

George was great! Good for him, he picked a song in his range and something he could make his own, I really enjoyed him.

Diana- No, not good. I thought it was way too cheezy, fake and it just did nothing for me.

LaToya- I like her but I didn't think it was her best. But compared to the others she was much, much better.

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

Diana did better than the first part but I agree, not that impressive.

I thought LaToya did pretty good, especially the ending. Of course I still think George was better!

 

[wendyl]

I think Elton John is hard to sing--maybe that's part of the problem. George was the only one that was GREAT and FUN to watch and listen to.

The bottom three will be hard to predict after this night!!!!!!!!!

 

[Robinrs]

I'm in SHOCK!
Jennifer BLEW me away!! She proved her "Disney worthiness" tonight!

I missed John Stevens, how was he?

 

[damo]

I am not a Jennifer fan, or a Circle of Life fan but wow, she really brought something to that song and made it memorable. She was the best of the night and Camile the worst. JPL, John Stevens and Diana weren't the greatest. The rest were their normal consistent selves.

 

[Rock'n Robin]

Excuse me if I'm on and off the boards for a few minutes, I'm voting for Jennifer a few times or so, and this week it's justified! It gave me Disney goosebumps!!
I only saw the recap of John Stevens doing "Crocodile Rock" but it looked pretty sorry....
Robin M.

 

[palmtreegirl]

Jennifer was really good, I love when she sings in her lower register. I was very impressed with her, good for her!

Bottom 3- John Stevens, Camille and JPL.

 

[Poohbear123]

Missed the first 40 min, got home in time to see Diana, Jennifer and George! George wowed me as usual, and I thought Diana was OK, but Jennifer was the bomb! From what I saw, Camille was her usual boring self.

 

[damo]

Originally posted by Robinrs
I'm in SHOCK!
Jennifer BLEW me away!! She proved her "Disney worthiness" tonight!

I missed John Stevens, how was he?

John sang Crocodile Rock. I wish he'd stop trying to be something he's not. Parts were good and parts were bad.

 

[pouncingpluto]

I voted for Jennifer probably 20 times last night.

I had no idea she was on the Wonder! I knew she was on a cruiseline, but not which one... and I kept having this feeling when I saw her... like I kept picturing her in one of those white muse outfits and with the big hair. I was on the Wonder last May... I bet she was performing on mine!

 

[Keggy]

Here is my take on AI:

George Huff has been my favorite from the beginning.

The Johns should have switched songs last night. They both sang songs not suited for their personalities.

My take on Jennifer H - when I first heard she had sang on DCL I thought she would of course be my favorite - but her personality is annoying. So, she won't get my vote.

I think personality plays a big part with this competition. There are some people on this show that ooze personality. There are others that don't. Latoya is amazing but she has shown a lot of personality and I think that will hurt her in the end.

The two worst of the night, for me, were John Stevens and Camille. Camille is just awful. It hurts to listen to her - I can't believe she has made it this far.

Kelly