We have stayed at the Hilton many times through priceline. It is worth the $60 for the ability to walk to DD Disney! We have always received a room facing DD and watched the fireworks everynight.
The rooms are average, but not as small as some other hotels. The pool area is nice and they have 2 pretty large pools and a kiddie pool. I guess it just makes a difference of what is important to you. We would choose the Hilton over the All-Stars anytime as my family values the extra amenities. ie: mainly the walking distance to DD, hot tubs, sauna room, Neutrogena bath products, sit down restaurants, just to name a few.
All that being said, we are also DVC members and nothing compares to that!