Which would you choose???

[cph706]

Haven't cruised since before the pandemic, last time was 2018 when our family of 4 went on a 4 night on the Dream in a one bedroom suite. This time its just me and DH. Started looking and have narrowed it down to 4 nights on the Dream in room 12504 or 4 nights on the Magic in room 8082. Price is about the same, dates are within 3 weeks of each other. We are retired and can drive to Port Everglades (so no hotels/flights).

Which would you pick???

 

[allashore]

Haven't cruised since before the pandemic, last time was 2018 when our family of 4 went on a 4 night on the Dream in a one bedroom suite. This time its just me and DH. Started looking and have narrowed it down to 4 nights on the Dream in room 12504 or 4 nights on the Magic in room 8082. Price is about the same, dates are within 3 weeks of each other. We are retired and can drive to Port Everglades (so no hotels/flights).

Which would you pick???

Magic Concierge Lounge is so much nicer, it was recently expanded. We don't care for the Dream & Fantasy lounges because you can not see outside and they are very small, the outside part on deck 13 does have a hottub thou. You will have different shows then you had on Dream.

 

[Lillebelle]

+1, if we're just talking about concierge experience, Magic is superior. The renovations they did are gorgeous and it's arguably the best lounge in the fleet now (yes the Wish has fancier food but you'll get more personalized service on the Magic). If you've never sailed small ship concierge, I definitely recommend it.

The only reason to pick the Dream would be if you want some of the amenities the Magic does not have (larger adult district, ice cream shop, mini golf, AquaDuck). But four nights is short enough I think you'll find plenty to do on the Magic to fill your time.

 

[cph706]

Some excellent points! We decided to do the Magic as suggested and are super excited! Thanks!

 

[OpieDoodle]

Dream is wonderful but you'll love the magic! We have been on the Dream twice and magic once and the magic is now our favorite ship! Enjoy your trip