Which TS ADR would you drop?

[Praying Colonel]

Right now we have 1 too many TS restaurants booked for the DDP credits we'll have available to us. We need to drop one. Which one would you drop?

ETA: Alfredo's is a replacement due to the Teppanyaki refurb extension. We get the VIP Illuminations with this. Not sure if that should make a difference or not.

 

[disney09]

I was not crazy about Alfredo's the only time I've been there, I mean, it's good but I've eaten in a lot of good italian restaurants.
Kona is very good, and also Le Cellier. Haven't been to Spoodles (will go in 3 weeks exactly) or Narcosees (spl?) but I've read a lot of good reviews of both, so my vote goes to Alfredo's.

 

[pixiemel]

I would drop Spoodles. We have never tried it, but really like all of your other choices!

 

[Microcell]

I know everyone raves bout it, but Kona is no more that a glorified hotel restaurant. I did not find it to be special in any way. I had the Tonga Toast even, not that special IMO!

 

[Clotho]

I see that Alfredo's is currently winning out. But of course remember that this is your last chance to eat there, since they close on the 31st! I would make sure to hit there one last time. We loved it on our trip, and are going their closing night.

 

[helenabear]

I wouldn't drop Alfredo's if you get VIP Illuminations viewing. Wouldn't be worth it to me to drop that.

For me it would be Spoodles... eaten there twice and both times YUCK!

 

[ParkPrincess]

I picked Spoodles. I've never eaten there, but I've eaten at the others. They're great! Plus, you've got the viewing for Illuminations at Alfredos, so I didn't select that one.

 

[angiedora]

I voted Spoodles, Good luck choosing!

 

[Eeyore3838]

I voted Spoodles. I was torn between Spoodles and Alfredos until I saw the blurb about the VIP illuminations. Spoodles is just an OK restaurant IMHO.

 

[tluvstink]

I voted for Spoodles. And I agree with some of the other posters that you should keep Alfredos. This will probably be your last chance to eat there.

Terri

 

[lynninpa]

I choose Spoodles. It has a small, very limited menu.

 

[MEK]

I wasn't that impressed with Spoodles when I ate there last November. It wasn't bad. It just wasn't memorable. I liked your other choices and I wouldn't drop the VIP Illuminations.

 

[maraki527]

I was going to say Alfredo's until i read the VIP seating....I would drop Spoodles. Both times I ate there it was just ok. I left out of there both times hungry.

 

[marlynnp]

Spoodles!
We were very disappointed with the food and service - it's was just blah

 

[DisneyNotes]

Alfredo's.

 

[DiszyDeanette]

I see that Alfredo's is currently winning out. But of course remember that this is your last chance to eat there, since they close on the 31st! I would make sure to hit there one last time. We loved it on our trip, and are going their closing night.

We loved Alfredos! The food was good, not spectacular. And the restaurant was way too crowded. But the server and rest of the staff helping out was FANTASTIC. I dropped an extra $20 on the tip and hunted down the manager to let him know how pleased we were with the level of interaction. It was a really fun evening.