Sean, as an exchanger, you would benefit greatly from joining
TUG - Timeshare Users Group so that you could read the resort reviews. It's $15/first year and well worth it for anyone who exchanges each year.
There are many terrific resorts in the Orlando area. Most have multiple reviews by TUG members. Based on the details given in these reviews, you would be able to get a pretty good idea of which are best suited to your needs and what to expect.
We would be very happy with any of these RCI resorts (alphabetical order):
Cypress Harbour (Marriott)
Cypress Pointe Grandvillas
Cypress Pointe Resort
Fairfield Orlando at Cypress Palms
HGVC at Sea World
Oasis Lakes
Royal Palms (Marriott)
Sabal Palms (Marriott)
Sheraton Vistana Villages
Silver Lakes Resort
We would also be willing to try a trade into any of these RCI resorts (alphabetical order):
Celebration World Resort
Embassy at Grand Beach
Orange Lake CC
Sheraton Vistana Resort
Sunterra Grand Beach
Sunterra Polynesian Isles
Vacation Village at Parkway
There are a few others that we would accept if they were all that was available and we needed reservations under 60 days ahead. HTH!