I would go with Narcoosee's. I love the atmosphere of being near the lagoon and being able to see the electric water parade and the fireworks. The food is excellent, especially the desserts. Citrico's is yummy, too. I just prefer the atmosphere at Narcoosee's, Also, last year,our server at Narcoosee's could not have been friendlier. I have never been to Artist Point. We've stayed at WL, but the menu just did not appeal to me as much. I used to be a big Flying Fish fan, but on our last visit, they messed up the order of ADRs and had us waiting for over an hour. I know an ADR is not a guarantee of anything, but when we checked in they told us we would have a table in no more than 20 minutes. When we asked what happened, the CMs weren't even particularly nice about it.