Which restaurant do you like better...

[LBlovesM&WDW]

I've only eaten at 2 out of the 3, never eaten at Via Napoli since my tummy doesn't do well with tomatoey Italian food. I'd pick 50s Prime Time-never had a bad meal there.

I also can't have the acidity of tomato based food, but Via Napoli has white pizza that is delish--just thought you should know.

 

[IndyRnRfan]

50's
Via
Garden Grill

Many people love Via's pizza and that is only what I can speak for since that is all we had. IMO, their pizza is overrated. Again, my opinion only, but I'd got to Splitsville for pizza and atmosphere. TV's, bowling, much more upbeat, etc... If you are looking for a quite atmosphere and pizza I'd take Via if you've never been, you might really like it. For us, it is number 3 on the list for pizza at WDW.

 

[Micca]

We've done all three, Via Napoli is the clear choice here. I will say that I am less enamored with VN than most folks here, but it is better than the other two by some measure.

 

[mom2AidanAndEli]

Via Napoli by far. 50's is okay. I thought it was fun, but when we went the kids were very young and didn't "get" it. They were confused by the shtick.

Garden Grill is on my entire family's "never again, even if you paid me" list!

 

[Megara5115]

i have only eaten at Garden Grill and I would not recommend it... Food was not good and I also did not like the weird musty smell. If I had to try one of the other two next it would definitely be Via Napoli!

 

[Tonberry]

I'd choose between 50's and Via Napoli and pick the place that has the food that you and your family like better.
I personally enjoy the food at 50's more than Napoli. Honestly, you can't go wrong with either of these two.

 

[mrocco90]

Garden Grill is our favorite of the 3. It's a meal we have to do every trip. Characters are great and we really enjoy the food. I love the salad, turkey and the dessert.