DH and I stayed at the Wilderness Lodge in 1997 and we loved it! We went again in 1998 and stayed at the Beach Club. The pool there is GREAT, but we found the resort itself to be very noisy. We wouldn't stay there again. We are going in May to stay at the Grand Floridian, and we are very excited! I have only been to WDW 3 times in my life (went once with my parents when I was a kid and stayed at the Contemporary), but I would say that the Wilderness Lodge was my favorite hotel by far!