which deluxe for 4 adults??

[cwt580]

we are goin may 2013.... already done Poly and WL. looking for another deluxe for a graduation/anniversary trip....


our choices so far:

#1...BC gardenview
#2...BW
#3 YC

2 queens will work for us just fine. parents and 2 college grads(girls).....we dont spend alot of time with pools...

 

[CastlesandDreams]

I vote for Yacht Club---- it's my favorite. Great location for Epcot and DHS. The pool is awesome, too.

 

[Jestocost]

BC is closer to Epcot than YC and BWI. BWI is closer to DHS. At garden view level I don't think there's an appreciable difference in rooms or amenities.

For something completely different, I would consider a Savannah View room at AKL.

 

[MMS1125]

any of the 3 would be great Since you already did the Poly I'd vote BC

 

[cwt580]

AKL is out...asked participants but the transpo options and remote location gave it the boot from our list...

 

[mickeynut1]

Out of the 3, we have only stayed at the BC, which is a great resort. But with that said, my choice would be the BWI, although you really can't go wrong with any of them. If you have a hard time deciding, I would look at them again and go with the one that the theme/decor appeals to you the most.

 

[cwt580]

thats the hard part.. we like em all. heard YC doesnt have the best food locations except steakhouse....BWI has no food in resort....


we think we would like some nighttime activities and a relaxing place at the sametime. first time for DD and BFF to be of legal drinking age at the world so that puts a different spin on our stay..we are not diehard park walkers but go to one each day....


only going to b able to afford gardenview at best so which fits best???


PS we will be on the deluxe dining plan w/ NO park hoppers.

 

[cjsm&d]

thats the hard part.. we like em all. heard YC doesnt have the best food locations except steakhouse....BWI has no food in resort....


we think we would like some nighttime activities and a relaxing place at the sametime. first time for DD and BFF to be of legal drinking age at the world so that puts a different spin on our stay..we are not diehard park walkers but go to one each day....


only going to b able to afford gardenview at best so which fits best???


PS we will be on the deluxe dining plan w/ NO park hoppers.

YC is a great choice for 4 adults. Guaranteed a full balconey. As for food, I think they have the best in resort options of the 3. Captains Grille is very good for breakfast, lunch and dinner, the Crew's Cup is nice place for apps or dinner with a few pops, and while Beaches and Cream is supposedly part of BC, it is really right between the two resorts. Of course there is the Steak House.


BC has Cape May, and while it's very good, you can walk over there any time for a meal, and along with Beaches and cream, that's it. They do have a grab and go market for sandwiches and stuff.

 

[Sue M]

BC/YC. Great location, theming, and great pool. In May I'd be in that pool :good vibes We sure loved it in Aug!

 

[SingingMom]

Just to throw another idea out there - we love the Dolphin! Location is wonderful, great restaurants, beautiful pools, spa.....it's Disney without overdoing it. We stayed five years in a row, took a cruise and an Adventures by Disney trip, and now are returning to the Dolphin!

 

[cwt580]

dont think swan and dolphin offer dining plan....

 

[vicki_c]

dont think swan and dolphin offer dining plan....

Correct. They do not.

 

[TinkerbellinLouisian]

thats the hard part.. we like em all. heard YC doesnt have the best food locations except steakhouse....BWI has no food in resort....


we think we would like some nighttime activities and a relaxing place at the sametime. first time for DD and BFF to be of legal drinking age at the world so that puts a different spin on our stay..we are not diehard park walkers but go to one each day....


only going to b able to afford gardenview at best so which fits best???


PS we will be on the deluxe dining plan w/ NO park hoppers.

Okay I have NOT stayed at Boardwalk or Yacht Club but we have stayed at BC about 5 times because we LOVE the pool

That being said... for the OP's family I would say BOARDWALK is the choice...

At Boardwalk you have "easy to get to" fabulous dining options (and drinking/nightlife options) to the Boardwalk....
Keyboarders, Flying Fish, etc.

BC and YC folks WALK to Boardwalk for those options but they are there right at your fingertips... so Boardwalk is my suggestion. You can WALK To EPCOT and DHS as well....

PLUS The Boardwalk options... great options there... have a magical visit !

Mary