Which cruise in Oct. 2004?

[ToDisney]

Okay, here's the deal. We were on the May 17th Eastern. We'd like to book another and October 2004 looks like best time. DH would love to do a Western (although we've been to Grand Cayman and Cozumel on a different cruise line years ago). I would eventually like to do the Western, too... BUT the Eastern leaves on my birthday AND they'll stop in Antigua instead of St. Martin. I'm thinking I'd like to try the different port since we can do the Western next time AND it is my birthday . WWYD?

 

[Surfergirl]

We have done the Eastern and are booked for the Oct. 9 ,2004 Western since the rest of the family all want that route. I would love to do the Eastern with Antigua but can't convince the rest of the gang.
i say go on the Eastern and celebrate your birthday!But which ever you choose, you are on the Magic and will have a ball.