Which ADR should I keep-Coral Reef or Cap'n Jack's

[mickey mommy]

I have 2 ADR's and am not sure which one to keep. One is for Coral Reef (7:00pm on 8/16) and the second is for Cap'n Jacks (5:10 on 8/16). The problem is we have 6 in our party. 4 of which are small children (9,8,7,1) and we could only get ADR's at CJ's for 2 tables. I was reading the mixed reviews of Coral Reef and was having second thoughts. That's why I tried to get Capn Jacks. I was at Coral Reef more than 10 years ago and I loved it back then.

Question 1- Which one would you choose? Capn Jacks or Coral Reef

Question 2- Would they be able to sit us together at CJ's even though ADR is for 6 , but 2 tables?

Question 3 - Which would be better considering the ages of the kids?


Thanks in advance for the info! I'll make sure I post which one I cancel!

 

[beccasmom]

Question 1- Which one would you choose? Capn Jacks or Coral Reef -

CR For sure. The food is generally pretty good although if price is a major issue, be warned it is an expensive choice. CJ's food is okay but not particularly memorable. Great margaritas, though!

Question 2- Would they be able to sit us together at CJ's even though ADR is for 6 , but 2 tables?

My guess is you'd be pretty close...it is not a large place.

Question 3 - Which would be better considering the ages of the kids? CR...the glass aquarium wall is endlessly fascinating for kids - and some of us adults! CJ's view is also quite nice, but doesn't quite compare for the kids.

 

[*Belle*]

We vote for Coral Reef. We eat here every trip. It's a must for DS8. He just loves this dinner.

 

[mickey mommy]

Thank you. We probably will stick with Coral Reef and cancel Captain Jacks. I'll bet you are right about the kids enjoying the Aquarium! It was a favorite of mine last time we were there.

 

[LuvTony0508]

Well, my vote is for Cap't Jacks. I ate at CR last year and loved it, however we ate at Cap't Jacks twice this year. Loved the lobster tail. It's a matter of preference regarding the menu.

 

[budbeerlady]

Keep Coral Reef, captn Jacks wasnt that good and there was nothing for kids to do but color.