Which 2 would you cancel?

[MomRN]

We are on the Dining Plan and have 2 reservations too many. I'm just curious to see what others would cancel. Here they are:

10-2 Mama Melrose lunch (Fantasmic dinner package)
10-3 Liberty Tree dinner
10-4 Garden Grill dinner
10-5 Ohana dinner
10-6 Tusker House breakfast/Boma dinner (if we do the Halloween party, it will be this night and we will have to cancel Boma. I'm disappointed, I really wanted to try it, but I don't know how much of a hit it would have been with everyone else)
10-7 Kona
10-8 Ohana breakfast (this is likely the 2nd cancellation, since we will have already been there)
10-9 Le Cellier lunch

Traveling with myself, dh, sd (17), and ds (5). My husband is the ultimate picky eater, and is more apt to like Liberty Tree the best. The 17 year old isn't necessarily picky, just doesn't eat much- usually. Last year we were able to split most CS meals with her and ds 5, because he's picky and hit and miss on an appetite.

 

[starousse]

Garden Grill and Ohana Breakfast

 

[newdeal]

Depends if you want to cancel breakfasts or dinners. I personally would cancel any breakfasts as to me its not worth it we just eat an early lunch and a nice dinner. If you want the breakfasts then i would cancel liberty tree and garden grill

 

[mom2dina]

I would cancel Liberty Tree and Boma

 

[autismgoesdisney]

Depends when you are going. If you are going when its really busy, then I'd cancel Liberty Tavern and Garden Grill. If you are going when its not that busy, then I'd cancel Liberty Tavern and Mama Melrose.

Just my opinion

 

[disneyplanningdad]

I would cancel the Fantasmic package. I have done it and the seats stink. People were coming in after we had to arrive and were getting better seats. Also, I'm from NY so I don't do Italian in WDW.

 

[MinnieLovesMickey]

I would cancel Boma, tried it back in December and I can't figure out what all the hype is about.

 

[momto2inKC]

I would cancel Liberty Tree Tavern and Boma.

 

[DONALD38]

Fantasmic Package and the Garden Grill.

 

[septbaby]

You're entitled to do something you'd like. I'd try to change the Tusker/Boma day to Boma breakfast. It is that good with enough basic things to appeal to everyone. My picky then 7yo loved Boma breakfast so much he'll tell you its awesome AND we went back as cash customers since we didn't have have any TS credits left.

I've been there for breakfast 5 times and 4 times we paid cash. There is no other TS meal I can say the same for at WDW.

Cancel Liberty Tree and either Ohana meal. There are lots of good CS choices in MK, so you can still get a good meal there using those credits. The Ohana bkfast will be a character meal, so if you want that then cancel the dineer.

 

[LBlovesM&WDW]

Garden Grill and Ohana Breakfast

These would be my choices as well. As for Boma, there are so many things to choose from. The soups are so good--I wasn't a soup person before my experience there.

 

[Gmouse]

We are on the Dining Plan and have 2 reservations too many. I'm just curious to see what others would cancel. Here they are:

10-2 Mama Melrose lunch (Fantasmic dinner package)
10-3 Liberty Tree dinner
10-4 Garden Grill dinner
10-5 Ohana dinner
10-6 Tusker House breakfast/Boma dinner (if we do the Halloween party, it will be this night and we will have to cancel Boma. I'm disappointed, I really wanted to try it, but I don't know how much of a hit it would have been with everyone else)
10-7 Kona
10-8 Ohana breakfast (this is likely the 2nd cancellation, since we will have already been there)
10-9 Le Cellier lunch

Traveling with myself, dh, sd (17), and ds (5). My husband is the ultimate picky eater, and is more apt to like Liberty Tree the best. The 17 year old isn't necessarily picky, just doesn't eat much- usually. Last year we were able to split most CS meals with her and ds 5, because he's picky and hit and miss on an appetite.

I would cancel Mama Melrose and replace with Tutto Italia. MM is AWFUL, service is terrible. Price is not worth using a TS. I would cancel Liberty Tree-it's just "OK" but again, not worth a TS-replace it with another night at Kona or LeCellier or Chef Mickey's Breakfast. Can't say for Garden Grille or Tusker House.

 

[stitch34]

Well, since you say you have picky eaters... I would cancel Ohana dinner and maybe Boma... though you really would like to try it, and yeah, need something for YOU! But Ohana dinner... we're picky, so that's why have never done it, nothing there for us. And then can skip the aggravation of the long wait to get seated there.

As for Liberty Tree and Garden Grill... we LOVE Garden Grill.. but Liberty Tree, a big yucko to us. And since they are similar meals, both turkey, maybe one of them should go.

 

[soarinup]

Garden Grill and Ohana Breakfast

That's my vote too

 

[Gmouse]

Well, since you say you have picky eaters... I would cancel Ohana dinner and maybe Boma... though you really would like to try it, and yeah, need something for YOU! But Ohana dinner... we're picky, so that's why have never done it, nothing there for us. And then can skip the aggravation of the long wait to get seated there.

As for Liberty Tree and Garden Grill... we LOVE Garden Grill.. but Liberty Tree, a big yucko to us. And since they are similar meals, both turkey, maybe one of them should go.

OH-You don't know what you're missing friend! Ohana has ALL YOU CAN EAT skewers of grilled chicken, pork, steak, turkey and shrimp! What other meat is left? Unless you are vegetarian-it's not the place for youTthe sides can be a little shaky-but with our son who is picky-he will eat ALL of the meats...probably none of the sides, but that's ok....we'll make up for it! Besides- I feel like the meat is worth what we pay alone It is GREAT...and right next to it is Kona- another MUST. EVERYTHING IS FABULOUS!!! We have ressies for there 3 TIMES, Ohana 1 time (only because that's all we can find right now) Tutto Italia 2 times and working on getting LeCellier and CRT

 

[mcd2745]

Garden Grill and Boma

 

[goofyintoronto]

I would cancel the Fantasmic package. I have done it and the seats stink. People were coming in after we had to arrive and were getting better seats. Also, I'm from NY so I don't do Italian in WDW.>>> HAHAHA

I would cancel Garden Grill and Boma (or if you wanna keep Boma, i'd cancel the Fantasmic package for the same reason the above poster said. Seats not great). Tusker House breakfast on the other hand is AWESOME!!!! HIGHLY recommend it. The biggest selection i've seen yet!

Although if you've already been to Ohana breakfast, maybe its not a bad idea to cancel that one?

I personally love Liberty Tree food, so I wouldnt cancel that one.

Good luck!

 

[youcansmellit]

Garden Grill and Ohana Breakfast

I agree

Garden Grill is so so at best.
and Ohana breakfast is nothing special.

 

[rapunzels]

I would cancel Garden Grill and Boma. While you may want to eat at Boma, if it's not something your kids will eat, it's awful expensive to waste the money if your kids don't eat. I doubt they would let the kids share at a buffet.

 

[daaasmith]

I am assuming you probably want to keep some character meals for the little one. We enjoy Garden Grill, Tusker, and Ohana. I guess if I was to cancel one of those, it would probably be Ohana (but Stitch is a riot) for food only. It is not 'bad' food, just family style and less variety than Tusker bk. As for the others, I would get rid of Mama Melrose and/or possibly Liberty Tree. You will get a variety of opinions, as everyone has different tastes. Hope you have a great trip and it works out for you!