DisneyMomFanatic
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2007
- Messages
- 1,133
Day 4 Tonys Town Square Lunch
So after some rides and picture taking at Magic Kingdom, we headed to our lunch reservation at Tonys. I go to check in and the CM tells me we are early by about 45 minutes. What???

Now I will tell you that the last time we dined there, I didnt have a great experience. It wasnt anything horrible, but bad moments stick in my memory from Disney because you arent supposed to have them when you are in the happiest place in the world. It takes me a while to get over bad experiences at restaurants. I dont go back for a long time or ever. But on this trip, since we were on the deluxe plan, and had so many credits, and DH wanted to go here again, I relented and we went.


So we started with appetizers and I wanted something on the lighter side. Not so sure I succeeded but I went with the
Toasted Cheese and Garlic Bread - topped with fresh Tomatoes and Basil

It looked really good and was not quite light but good. Now at some point after it arrived, I asked myself WHY did you order this Karla??? I have to be in just the right mood to have slices, pieces, or chunks of tomatoes on my food. This was not one of those times and I managed to wipe most of them off. But holy moley goodness Basil!!!

Next was my DH, he said he wanted something different and went with the
Seasonal Fruit - with prosciutto

It was cantaloupe and prosciutto with some dark sauce. It as salty, sweet goodness. He said he would eat it again but it wasnt the greatest gift but it was good.
DD and DS both opted for the same item. They each chose the
Calamari - topped with Olive Relish and served with a side of Marinara Sauce

They both liked this but said that they liked Raglan Roads better. They werent as fond of the breading on this one as much as at RR, but they ate it!
On to our entrees: DS knew immediately what he was going to have because if you remember correctly, his favorite food is??? If you guessed shrimp, you are correct. So he got the
Shrimp Scampi - Linguini with Sun-dried Tomatoes and Asparagus tossed in a Garlic Sauce

He loved the shrimp, he said they were juicy and cooked right. He liked the pasta, but wasnt hungry enough to eat it all because it was a huge portion. He didnt touch the veggies that were in it.
DH had no idea what he wanted. He decided he wanted something small. Ever get a small Italian anything??? Yeah, me either!

Meatball Sliders - Meatballs cooked in Marinara Sauce topped with provolone and arugula on Focaccia rolls

They were good and he would get them again. He really like the homemade chips that were served with them. He was pleasantly surprised by this plate. He went into this dish just to get something small and found something good.
DD also had decided rather quickly what she was going to have. She went with the
Chicken Parmigiana - Lightly Breaded Chicken Breast with Marinara Sauce topped with Melted Mozzarella over Spaghetti

She loved this. The breading was light and had just enough cheese to give it some good flavor. She barely touched the pasta. This was the dish I had gotten last time that gave me the bad experience. When it came out last time and I was eating it, it had some other components on the chicken and in the dish that werent listed on the menu. I hated it and was afraid to order it this time. I was also afraid for DD when she wanted to order this. But I didnt want to taint her view of this dish by saying that I didnt like it last time. It wasnt fair to her to unduly influence her (whether or not she knew thats what I would have been doing). So I kept my mouth shut and let her order it. Thankfully this time the meal didnt include any extraneous items. So, I didnt order this, instead I ordered the
Spaghetti - with choice of Meatballs or Sweet Italian Sausage with Marinara Sauce

I got this dish with the sweet Italian sausage. I had maybe 8 bites of the spaghetti and 5 of the sausage. I wasnt a fan. Here is where I think the problem with Tonys is for me. I am 50% Italian. My Moms side of the family is all Italian and we had the Sunday dinners with the whole kit and caboodle. I have seen the love and devotion put into the food from the time I could stand and the stories to go with it. This is restaurant Italian, it is NOT the same thing and to me a VERY inferior product. Now, having said that, it is GOOD restaurant Italian food, as verified by my DH, but for me, it is just not the same. I love the decor and the server was great. We had Jihane. She kept us hydrated and checked in with us to make sure everything was ok. Then we went onto dessert and I have to say that as Italian as I am when it comes to entrees, I am not when it comes to dessert. I am not fond of tiramisu at all!

Spumoni - layers of ice cream with pistachio nuts and cherries


I dont know what I was thinking I would get, but it wasnt this. I think my head was thinking a glass cup with some ice cream, then a layer of pistachios and some more ice cream then some cherries. But it wasnt thinking this block of ice cream. It was ok but weird. DH ordered the same thing as I did. Our Server was very nice. She noticed that we had our anniversary pins on and with our dessert plates she included a timkerbell light on mine and a buzz lightyear light on DHs. It was very sweet of her and it was unexpected because that was the first time on the trip any of our servers did something for our anniversary. We had plenty of people wish us Happy Anniversary but this time she gave us something. It made us smile a bit. Of course, it was short lived because DD immediately took them off our hands.
The kids decided to get gelato, chocolate. (sorry, no picture)
So thus ends our Tonys adventure. We had a good meal, if not extraordinary. I just cant really like this place. I kind of want to, but cant. I always think about how it was at family gatherings and it just cant live up to those memories. Sorry Tonys. The service was good, the atmosphere nice and sweet and the food ok. I dont know when or IF we will be back.
We are giving this meal a
3-3 ½

It cost us $135.63 or 4 TS credits or $33.91/credit
UP NEXT: We head to Ohana for dinner. We have more than 4 in our party and a nice Meet! Stay tuned to see who all the extras are.