We almost always exclusively stay at the Grand Legacy (previously Ramada Maingate). As you can see from my siggy below, we've stayed there often. Our October reservation is for Grand Legacy at $145 per night (
AAA/AARP - husband is in 50s - discount, and got free parking deal - parking used to be free, then $5, now $12/night). When it was Ramada, we'd usually get the SAME room for about $100-$125/night for SAME timeframe. Prices have gone up with the construction. I booked our Feb 2016 rooms for $90/night when it was still Ramada, and our stay commenced the week after the name change - I have a feeling those prices are LONG gone. We always request what used to be called "premium" then "deluxe view with fireworks" now "deluxe 2 queen" room, as the rooms are larger than the "classic" room - tucked on the 3rd/4th floor. Elevator accessible, free nibbles in the morning (donuts, fruit, cereal, toast, bagels - PERFECT for us!). The new breakfast room supposedly opening very, very soon (if not already).
We like the Deluxe room better than the new premier/superior because the showers are adjustable (pressure), and there is only 1 sink. With 2 adults, 2 kids, that extra counter space next to the sink is really appreciated. Also in the deluxe room, there was better "space" for putting all our cr*p. Beds all comfy, pillows good & plenty. They also give coupons to local places on Harbor as you check in - we had a 20% off Dennys, a pizza coupon of some kind, 10% off McDonald's.
The walk to DLR main entrance is pretty sweet - 7 minutes dragging with kids. They've got stroller rental in the building too. The pool is AWESOME - open early and stays open late. We're holding a DL-facing room at HoJos for the same dates, same price, but the hours for the water play don't start until later, so kids would lose at least 2 hours in the pool our last morning. Not sure we want to try it. HoJos front desk told me when I called that if really chilly (possible in Oct), the pool could have shorter hours, water features included, even though they are "heated". Heading back to Chicago, that last Saturday morning pool time is KEY. I like the pool at Grand Legacy A LOT for littles - it is zero-entry, and stays less than 3 feet for a good part, so my 7-year old, who doesn't like "deep water", can frolic nicely. The kids love the water cannons and sprayers too on deck. The GL pool will be open whether it is 50 degrees out or 100. Doesn't close for weather. In February, my kids were at the GL pool at 10pm in 60 degree weather - IN THE RAIN - having the time of their lives. Again, coming from Chicago during a very cold spell, that was HEAVEN for them.
We looked into the new courtyard - it looks AWESOME! But, the slide timing (the front desk says the slides don't get turned on until about 30 minutes after the pool opens at 10), again doesn't work when we need to check out at noon for our flight back to Chicago. Our stay for 3 days would be close to $1000 - parking not included, no breakfast. Nor does the timing work when we come back from a day at Universal (~8pm). Both instances - morning or night, we can hop in the pool at the Grand Legacy!
We tried to rent points at the Grand Cal. to check it out, but NO POINTS were available to rent as we tried too late. Honestly - renting points for GCH would've been cheaper than the Courtyard!!! Insane. For the price, we feel we can't beat the Grand Legacy, and we know exactly what we're getting, so that's nice to know too.