My girls love to get charms for their bracelets.
I always get a bag of Mickey truffles.
At the holidays, I buy the Mickey gingerbread kits that come with a little Mickey cookie cutter.
Nothing much beyond that unless I run across something unusual or one of those things that catches your fancy. In that category I have:
*a ToT pin that is in the shape of a hotel key and a Mad tea party pin (cool 3D with spinning cups)
*a ToT bathrobe (love it!!!! thanks so much to my sister and 2 DIS friends for buying it for me since I've wanted it forever!)
*tile with a tree on it from GCH
As a kid, I always wanted something from the glassblowers. I had a pirate ship, a Tinkerbell, and a small castle. I finally got a personalized crystal mug last year after wanting one for about 40 years.
I have some old things from many years ago...things you'd never find in DL today

because it's all so much more generic. I have a gold parrot (ceramic) from the old shop near Pirates, Royal Doulton porcelain Alice and Cheshire cat figurines, a crystal and glass magic wand from the Magic shop and a few other things like that.
I am always drawn to the HM pins that change like the portraits in the ride when you hold up a little black light to them (which you can purchase separately). I can't bring myself to spend the $50 for them, though.
A couple of years ago my sis and I bought a bottle of Magicale.