I like it very much. Its bascially comfort food, a Thanksgiving meal of sorts. Turkey, ham, flank steak, mashed potatoes, stuffing, mac and cheese and green beans for the main course. It is served family style and is all you can eat. I really like the salad, it has a strawberry vinegarette that is really good and the rolls are also yummy. They have either apple or cherry cobble for dessert that is also good. My family loves this one, we enjoy the setting, the characters dressed in colonial garb and have had a good meal there several times. All that said however, there will be people who will swear the food is frozen, the meat is processed and it just generally stinks! And thats their right and opinion. I just seem to always see reviews that either love or hate the place, not a lot of in betweens! I say you always have to try something yourself to know for sure.
I also like Tony's and thats another one that generates a lot of passionate reviews of either love it or hate it! We ate there before
MVMCP in December and it was one of our favorite meals. We enjoyed the Lady and Tramp theming and while it wasn't the most authentic, incredilbe Italian food we have ever had, it became a must do for us. Again, you don't know until you try!
They are both great to do on party nights as they are right in the Magic Kingdom. Good luck with your choice!