beachblanket said:
Personally, I think the big mistake Disney made (which Universal didn't) was to separate the entertainment from the dining and retail. While the original vision for PI was that of a "mini park" (pay a single entrance fee at the gate for access to a range of "attractions," e.g. nightclubs), in practice that both "isolated" PI from all the other traffic at DTD and allowed the environment at PI to evolve in a different (and negative) direction from everything else in DTD.
Actually, when Pleasure Island opened, it was much as it is now, with a admission only needed for the clubs while one could freely roam the Island for retail and dining. This made it possible to sustain a higher quality retail presence and some interesting light dining (Merriweather's Market) , in addition to Portabello Yacht Club and Fireworks Factory. Mannequins was the only club that was exclusively 21 and over. XZFR Rockin Rollerdome was both a club and a roller rink.
Disney killed the Island in two ways, first they decided to charge admission to the Island itself instead of just to the clubs making it so only people going to Pleasure Island's clubs would actually enter the Island (this made it harder for Pleasure Island's retail and restaurants to survive). Next, they built Downtown Disney Westside which added more shops and restaurants and since they were charging admission to the Island, they built a bypass walk way for people to get between the Market Place and Westside.
By mixing all the Citywalk attractions together, Universal created a more dynamic experience, offering entertaining variety for people strolling through. The "mix" approach also prevented any one "clubby" area from becoming a teen ghetto.
Citywalk does not really mix the clubs and retail any more than Pleasure Island did when it opened (actually, it is just the opposite, Pleasure Island's clubs and restaurants were much more integrated than Citywalk's are). In fact, it is this integration that caused much of Pleasure Island's problems. During the day when the Island was open with no admission fee, it always seemed somewhat depressing because half the venues were closed (all its clubs). That all of Citywalk's clubs are on a different level means that people do not see them if they are not going to look for them and so are more comfortable strolling through its retail and restaurant locations.
Citywalk also benefits from the foot traffic from Islands of Adventure (people heading to and from their cars) whereas Pleasure Island is a destination of its own.
Finally, Citywalk got Emeril Lagasse (Emeril's Orlando) and Disney got Wolfgang Puck (no one makes a special trip to visit a Wolfgang Puck restaurant, whereas Emeril's draws lots of people even if they only want to buy shirts and have their picture taken in front of its sign).
/carmi