Oh! Definitely. I have stayed at both AKL and Poly. AKL is spectacular and lovely, but for NYE, Poly is the ticket. If you want to do something like 'Ohana's or dinner at California Grill or Chef Mickey's, you don't have to mess with taking the car. Just hop on the monorail. They pipe in the music from all the fireworks displays on NYE, so you get the "full effect." It was warm enough this past NYE to swim (not late in the evening, but all day long), so my DS, who loves that volcano pool, got to enjoy it. It's just too easy. AKL is pretty far out from everything that is happening to be convenient for NYE celebrations. Once again, it's a beautiful resort. It's just that you don't have the convenience of being close to anything. During the NY celebrations, when the crowds are at their peak, being close means something.
Julie