We had progressive, my rate was $964 at age 24, with one accident in 2001. 25/50 coverage, etc. On a new car.
Well, at age 25, which I turned in November it only went down about $5 a month, also the accident "dropped" off my record.
So I called Geico this week because my renewal is up with Progressive and guess what... I'm saving almost $100 a month now!! Call around. I know when I did a quote with Progressive online as a new customer the rate was much less than my current, their 800 #'s explanation, was that they offer cheaper rates to new customers! Bye Bye Progressive!