Day 5: Dinner and a Private Fireworks Show at Narcoossees
After a day full of food, waiting in lines, and enjoying our resort, what a better way to end the day than with...more food!
When we were making our ADR's, we knew we wanted to eat at one of the signature restaurants in our resort. DSis wanted Narcoossees. I wanted to try Citricos (because I hate seafood and Narcoossees specializes in seafood). She won...again
We had a really long day (despite sleeping in) and our ADR wasn't until 8:30. We booked it late so we could see Wishes from the restaurant and it was a perfect time for us because it gave us plenty of time to rest before dinner. And...since the restaurant was a three-minute walk from our room in the Big Pine Key building, we could guarantee we wouldn't be late this time!
Narcoossees is located near the boat launch to the MK. It's a beautiful, cosy area. At night, it's very dimly lit and very romantic. But because the restaurant is very dark at night, it's not a place for sleepy kids (or adults!). The lighting won't do you any favors to keep you awake.
We entered the restaurant and were handed a beeper (again), but had a short wait (around 10 minutes). The waiting area has a view of the open kitchen and it was interesting to watch what goes on in there.
While we were waiting, I was looking around and I noticed how dressed up everyone was! Many people, especially here, seem to talk down how dressy this place is, and just because you can wear jeans or shorts doesn't mean you should, or that you won't feel out of place. I wore a simple skirt and a dressy tank with some nice gladiator sandals and I felt a bit underdressed. Every man I saw was wearing a jacket or a very nice polo and I didn't see many women who weren't wearing sundresses or skirts. Narcoossee's has a very upscale feel to it, and I think that's why we enjoyed it so much. We do a lot of fine dining at home in Chicago and we love a good dining experience with good food. And, I love dressing up so dress codes never deter me, but rather they encourage me. I also didn't notice many kids in the restaurant. It really is a quiet, romantic place and I'm glad our experience went uninterrupted by screaming babies or kids running around.
After our beeper went off, we were seated at a table next to the window, looking out onto Bay Lake and the Contemporary. We had a perfect view of the Electrical Water Parade, too! The hostess handed each of us a personalized menu! This was a bit of a surprise, as we hadn't requested it, but the personal touch was so nice. They even brought us an envelope (without any prompting) so we could bring them home. I don't know if they do this for everyone, but little things like this really set Narcoossees aside from other restaurants on property.
Our server appeared quickly and took our drink orders. DM had an iced tea, DSis had a diet coke, and DGM and I both had a (I think) chocolate raspberry smoothie, which was very yummy and cooling on such a hot night. Our server also brought me out an ice water with my smoothie (which I appreciated).
She also brought over some hot, crusty bread and butter topped with sea salt. I was the only one who really liked the salt with the butter. I thought it really enhanced the flavor of the bread. Everyone else thought it was too salty.
DSis and DGM both started with the Heirloom Tomato Salad (with cantaloupe, prosciutto, house made mozzarella, creme fraise and aged balsamic). DGM loved it, DSis did not like it. She ate the tomatoes and the mozzarella, but she hated the texture of the proscuitto (I tried some and thought it was fantastic...she's never liked proscuitto before so this wasn't surprising). It was an interesting combination of flavors (the saltiness of the proscuitto and balsamic with the smooth mozzarella and creme fraise and the sweetness of the cantalope and tomatoes).
DM had the Romaine Salad (Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmigiano-reggiano cheese). It was a caesar salad that tasted, well, like any other caesar salad.
I had the Artesian Cheeses (Humboldt Fog, Rogue River Oregon Blue, Aged Canadian White Cheddar). The Humboldt Fog and the Aged Canadian Cheddar were excellent, but the Oregon Blue was very musky and heavy. The cheeses were accompanied by cranberry crisps, sticky candied walnuts, cranberries, and dried fruit, and they worked very well with the cheeses. The sticky candied walnuts neutralized the blue cheese very well, I thought.
For her main course, DM had the Surf and Turf (Grilled Filet Mignon and Butter-Poached Lobster Tail, potato gratin and bearnaise sauce). Her filet was cooked perfectly and her lobster was so good she barely used the drawn butter.
DSis ordered the Free Range Chicken Breast ("loaded" mashed potatoes, baby spinach, Nueske's Bacon vinaigrette) and really enjoyed it. The chicken was tender and flavorful and the potatoes were very good (I snuck a taste and agreed), but she didn't dig the spinach.
DGM and I both ordered the Grilled Filet Mignon (potato gratin and bearnaise sauce) and it might have been one of the best filets of beef I've ever had. It was tender, cooked perfectly, and the creamy bearnaise sauce enhanced the tenderness of the beef. The potatoes were a bit better than the ones we'd had at the other restaurants (ahem Coral Reef), but were still not all that great. DGM and I both cleaned our plates. It was really a fantastic dish.
After dinner, we got our dessert menus, but since Wishes was starting, we headed outside to watch. I'm sure the couple whose table was looking out at the castle was a bit dismayed that everyone was standing in front of their table, but on such a warm, beautiful night, this was an experience that is really best outside. There weren't that many people out on the deck and as the music played on the deck, watching the fireworks at that distance over the water, was truly a magical experience.
We came back in to order our dessert and there were so many choices that we all had trouble choosing what to order!
DGM had the Strawberry Shortcake (vanilla bean whipped cream and strawberry sauce) and loved it. She loves fruity desserts and this really satisfied her, especially since the strawberries were fresh and not the canned or frozen kind.
DSis ordered the Warm Chocolate Almond Gateau (with vanilla bean whipped cream). She thought it was rich and heavy, but delicious. She loved the flavor and texture of the melting ice cream with the warm cake, but she couldn't finish it.
DM and I both ordered the Almond Crusted Cheesecake (with Lambert Cherry Sauce) and Oh.My.Gosh it was the best dessert I had on my trip. The toasted almonds, the almond flavored cheesecake, the tart cherries...SO good. DM agreed. She couldn't finish (it is a heavy dessert), but it was so good that I couldn't not finish.
After dinner, our server brought us the check and inside was a card to remind us not to forget to tip. I thought it was a bit tacky, but I suppose it's better than the server verbally reminding us to tip (which I had read about here). I know that with the changes to the
DDP, people had been forgetting to tip, or not tipping intentionally. We always tip (we left cash gratuities at every meal as to not rack up many charges on our KTTW) so the reminder was unnecessary, but again, I understand why. The service at Narcoossees is outstanding, the food is amazing, and the ambiance is unmatched. It's an upscale, quiet experience and the fireworks just enhance an already lovely experience.
After dinner, DM and DGM went back to our building to get ready for bed. DSis and I walked the grounds a bit and sat in the lobby enjoying the music for a little while before heading to bed, ourselves. We'd need the rest- we had a 7:30 am meeting with Mickey!
Up Next: An Early Morning Breakfast with Mickey and Friends!