Pat,
That's a hard question to answer, as each resort has it's own theme. Yes we really like VWL. It's quiet, I like the fact that it is on the large lake, use those mini boats allot. Close to MK and Camp Wilderness.
But Saratoga is nice also. It is allot more open, not as secluded as VWL but I guess it depends on the type of vacation you plan. On our last vacation in August/Sept, we stayed at both. We just wanted to relax, go to the parks every once in awhile, see the fireworks, eat in some of the restaurants, enjoy the other available items of Disney (we do not play golf) so that didn't interest us. We lounged around the pool, met a bunch of great people from the NE, introduced them to the DIS boards. When we transferred over to SSR for the final few days of our vacation we had planned to spend time at DTD, Disney Quest etc. Some of that didn't happen, a thing called a Hurricane got in the way, but we still enjoyed ourselves enough to make me add on there.
So I guess it just depends on the person/family and what you want out of your vacation. With
DVC we go enough times that the urge to rush around the parks like a mad-man as so many people do doesn't exist. We pick and choose what we want to do on each vacation and go with the flow.
Hope that answers your question.
That's just how we feel.
Kennyk