Definately have to second that it really depends on your kiddo. DD has never been afraid of the characters so she always ran right up to them. At 2, we did not give her an autograph book. She did take one on our last trip and enjoyed it. She looks at the book all the time. The characters do seem to be well trained to only sign on one side of the page so you can use them for scrapbooks. My only advise is to not force your child to go get autographs if they are scared. SUCH a pet peeve of mine...yes, I know you spent a lot of money and yes, I know you want a pic of your child with Mickey but if they are terrified...DON'T MAKE THEM DO IT! I see this every trip w/o fail.