West Coasters: Early or Late Dining for Caribbean cruises?

West Coasters: Main or Late Dining for Caribbean cruises?


  • Total voters
    31
We are doing the late dining on our upcoming cruise. Figure it will just work better for us and I prefer to not have to rush around to meet an early dining time. We are usually 7pmish eaters and DD can pretty much eat any time so long as we snack her up. I have no doubt she'll be way snacked up on the cruise. :)
 
We do early - breakfast is earlier, lunch is earlier so dinner needs to be earlier. I don't like going to bed stuffed, nor do I want to feel like snacking in the late afternoon but I do like having room during the evening shows in the adult areas to split one last beverage with my husband before bed. :)
 
When I posted this thread, I really wanted EVERYONE's opinions. And I do appreciate the differing viewpoints so I can make a better decision for ME. Thank you to all who have shared their experiences.

I think I'll stick with the late dining, as we will have 3 adults and just one little toddler on this cruise. My baby is pretty flexible and if she gets tired when we are in the MDR, she's good with me just holding her to sleep. I really like the fact that food options are so varied and plentiful so that if I get hungry before 815p I can get a snack. Also I don't mind going to bed with a full stomach. Win/win for me.:teeth:
 
I guess I'm in the minority. We are from AZ and have dinner around 6 every night at home. Therefore, we like to eat at the early seating. As mentioned, we don't like to go to bed right after eating. We enjoy going to the show and other activities after dinner to allow our stomachs to settle before bed. We often have early morning excursions so we can't sleep in.
 

Late seating. The earlier just seems too early. But to tell the truth even late seating seems late. Reason being it can take up to hour and half
for you to get the food and finish. Wish they had somewhere in the middle between the two times :)

Reading some of the posters on here talk about other Cruise lines anytime dining makes me wonder how that is?
 
We always do early dining no matter where we are cruising from/to. We live on the wet coast of Canada (yes, I meant "wet"). We are both early risers and I want to eat within an hour of waking because my blood sugar is low.
 
I always pick late seating but it has nothing do to with being from the west coast, nevertheless I do understand your logic regarding the time.
 
We are from AZ-have done 2 cruises with early seating and 1 with late and we liked late seating much better.
 
Did Late on DCL once. Never again. Even though I eat late at home, while I'm on vacation I tend to eat at more normal hours. By late seating, I'm ready to chew the paneling off the walls.
 
7 nights is not long enough to adjust to.

I so agree with you.

What's odd is that when DH is on a work trip going east, he'll adjust inside of a day. On a leisure trip there is NO WAY he is doing what he needs to do to adjust in a day. When he doesn't have a boss telling him what to do, he'll sleep in and not adjust.

DS and I have tried to adjust fast, and it just leads to feeling horrible by day 3 or 4 of the trip; we feel horrible day 3 or 4 anyway, so it's "be miserable waking up so early then feel bad day 3 or 4" or "wake up when we want to and feel bad day 3 or 4"....we choose the one with LESS feeling bad. :)

This is a terrible myth spread by a few, dinner time should be set by the time you eat at home not home time zone.

Why is it a myth if it's the experience of people. Do you think people just post for fun, post lies? To what point and purpose would that be done?

"eat at home" vs "home time zone"...do you mean "the time zone you're in" by "home" time zone?

On the ship you and your kids get up with the sun, have breakfast local time go off to port local time eat lunch local time in port or local time on ship or local time in castaway

I do NOT get up with the sun, and neither does my son, on the ship. I don't have breakfast local time; we often don't get breakfast at all on a ship unless we're at the very tail end of breakfast service. Of course we get off the ship local time, but that doesn't mean it's early! I don't eat lunch at lunchtime local time; in San Juan and St Maarten we ended up having lunch around 3pm, which is...drum roll please....around noon western time. And same on Castaway, we eat either at the very beginning of lunch service because we didn't have breakfast or towards the end because we did have breakfast and aren't yet hungry.

This myth comes every so often spread by one or two trying to be clever.

People aren't trying to be clever by posting their experiences. Not sure what's so clever about "you might not be adjusted to the timezone, and if you normally eat at 8pm your time, eating at 5pm your time might not feel great".

And we haven't found the perfect thing yet, anyway. It's all very dependent on the trip before the cruise portion, and how we've felt, etc. Although our stomachs are more ready for food at late seating, it splits up our evening too much. Except for DH and DS seeing Villains, or maybe a magic show or comedian, we don't go to the shows, so we do...nothing, then go to dinner, then there's about an hour or so before exhaustion hits and we go to bed. If we do early dining, we come back onboard, get ready, have dinner, then the whole evening feels far more open for us. DS gets some good kid's club time in, we can do whatever we're doing, and it feels like we can all stay up later than we would with food in the bellies.

I guess I'm in the minority. We are from AZ and have dinner around 6 every night at home. Therefore, we like to eat at the early seating. As mentioned, we don't like to go to bed right after eating. We enjoy going to the show and other activities after dinner to allow our stomachs to settle before bed. We often have early morning excursions so we can't sleep in.

Sounds like your family is really good at adjusting to the timezone. :)

Reading some of the posters on here talk about other Cruise lines anytime dining makes me wonder how that is?

When we had MyTimeDining on Royal, on embarkation day we went to the desk and set up a good time for that night. Then we set up all the other nights after thinking about what would work best. We've never done a true "anytime" dining because I saw the line (not horribly long, but I didn't want any line) on the first night and we were glad we had set up a time. It ended up being somewhere in between early and late seating for that cruise. On the first Royal cruise we took as a family we had MyFamilyTime dining which was at 5:30 and that was just really hard for us. BUT my son and I had spent the last 2.5 weeks on land being very sick (too sick to form the thought "let's buy face masks and go HOME, rest up, get well, and fly back for the cruise) and I had almost no sense of taste and smell (I could taste and smell coffee and dark chocolate and that was it for a month or so) so dining was hard anyway.
 
This is a terrible myth spread by a few, dinner time should be set by the time you eat at home not home time zone.

So you go to Florida maybe days or a week pre cruise and go onto local time. On the ship you and your kids get up with the sun, have breakfast local time go off to port local time eat lunch local time in port or local time on ship or local time in castaway , see where this is going,,,,, then swap to a different time zone for dinner so a gap of maybe seven whole hours.

Your body clock is on local time then you eat off a different time zone and go to bed straight away post a big dinner.This myth comes every so often spread by one or two trying to be clever. It doesn't work, PS If I was on the ship and eating dinner in my home time zone my MDR would be 2pm does that make any sense at all?

We eat at 8pm at home so we eat at 8pm on the ship. I adjust in a day going from west to east. I barely notice the change. Now coming home is a different story. The first few days we're home we eat dinner at 6(not normal for us) and I'm in bed at 8pm, and I'm super jet lagged for a week. Everyone adjusts to time change differently. I'm sure there are people that are complete opposite me and have trouble going from west to east.
 
We are from California as well, traveling with a 4 year old. We eat dinner at home around 6pm and I chose late dining. We will be cruising the Panama Canal and as we head back west, I just wanted to have the extra time in the ports. Some of the port "all aboard times" are not until shortly before early dining. I do not want to feel rushed. If we get hungry, we can order a cheese plate from room service or grab a small snack from quick service. It also gives us the option of seeing the early show...or skipping MDR and going to the late show if we are in port late.

When we travel we seem to start early and end late and usually spend most of the day snacking and then have a large dinner around 8pm...so I figured, based on our experience, late will work best for us.
 
Last November I took my wife and 3.5 year old son on the Western Caribbean Fantasy itinerary. We're from Calif, and I thought I was clever by spending a week beforehand at WDW and having them acclimate to EST. As a seasoned traveler, I adapt to time zones quickly, but I was surprised that even after a week they were still on west coast time. On the ship my son fall asleep for his nap till late, so we were always waking him up for the early dinner, and that led to him (and us) not enjoying the dinners as much. Next time I'll just adjust myself to staying on west coast time, getting up late and staying up late.
 
I adjust in a day going from west to east.

Oh you are so lucky!

Going back west I *like* staying on Eastern time. It's healthier for us, because it lets us go to sleep earlier and wake earlier. That's not my natural state, but in many ways it's nice to do that, so I try to stay on it. Never works, of course. :)
 
I have tried late dining once. I prefer early. Not sure what it will be like for Hawaii. All the other cruises were in my time zone or ahead. WBTA was fine eating early. I don't stay up too late on the ship, and I get up at a decent time.

A large meal at the end of the night (since I don't stay up too late) doesn't work for me.

Everyone is different, so you will have to go with what you think will work for you and your family.
 
Late dining. I can't adjust in a week. We sleep late on the east coast. We are definitely not up with the sun. I plan later excursions or we just don't do them. Early dining is just way too early when you are still on pacific time.
 
Oh you are so lucky!

Going back west I *like* staying on Eastern time. It's healthier for us, because it lets us go to sleep earlier and wake earlier. That's not my natural state, but in many ways it's nice to do that, so I try to stay on it. Never works, of course. :)

On the days I work I have to be up at 430 so the first few shifts once we get back home it's a breeze getting up, unfortunately I work 12 hours so I really start to fade by the end of the day. If we go to Europe I will need a weeks vacation to recover from my vacation.
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!

























DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top