I gotta be honest... As a guest, I love getting a welcome bag, but as a bride I skipped them, and nobody even noticed. I think really the only people who know to expect a welcome bag are those who have planned a destination wedding!
I decided not to make them because I had heard too many horror stories of couples spending precious pre-wedding time delivering them, hotel front desk agents forgetting to distribute them, and guests dumping most of what's in them. Not everyone has these experiences, but the chance that any or all of these things might happen was enough to make me direct my time and budget to different areas of planning.
Thanks lurkyloo! Saying that you love getting them makes me feel like I should do them

I know no one would notice if I didn't, but I think I might feel at some point like I was doing the bare minimum for them after they've done so much to be at my wedding. I think I will just make sure what I put in them is useful to minimize the chance of it getting trashed.
I love the idea of welcome bags! Especially when guests travel so far, I just think it's an extra-special way of saying "Thank you for being here!" The majority of our welcome bags were used, but that's because about 80% was food/snack type items and mini water bottles. It also gave us a nice way to hand out a copy of our welcome letter with all the info for the weekend.
I definitely love the idea of welcome bags too! At first I thought "yes, definitely doing that!" because we thought we wouldn't get many people coming. Now we're inviting more people I'm still happy to do it but I will care more if 30 bags go in the trash rather than 10. I was planning on doing what you did and putting food items and water bottles in there along with our welcome info and itinerary.
I too am doing them without question. In fact the actual bags were the first wedding item I bought after I got engaged. I think it is really nice for your guests to get something, espically when they are traveling so far. I am pretty much skipping the favors at the wedding because of the welcome bag. I plan on putting in snacks and water, mickey soaps that I am making, maybe little sunscreens, welcome letter, park maps, I'm Celebrating buttons, door hanger, and maybe a beach towel, IF I can swing it. I am only planning on giving them to people that stay ON property. I have heard from other brides if you put on a card, with the reservation number, the front desk should have no problem getting it to them.
I know how excited I get when I get things like this
Sarah, you saying you get excited about welcome bags also makes me want to do them! You mentioned adding a lot of the things I was thinking about adding. All things that I would use myself which is what I think my guidelines will be. If I would toss/ignore it, don't put it in there
for me, it was a fun project to keep me busy and i enjoyed it BUT i didnt do anything terribly fancy (simple bags, homemade info “brochure”, door hanger, candy, tissues, votive candle) and let me say that generally you (and other destination brides as carrie mentioned) will be WAY more into this then anyone else. and i only got involved as we were a relatively small wedding (32 total) AND i did one bag per “group”.
Thanks sambycat! I would have loved receiving one of your welcome bags!
i think welcome bags are a great idea, especially if you can find a way thats budget friendly. I think there will always be people or couples that look at the welcome bag and then pretty much disregard whatever is in it but most people will appreciate the gesture. I think if you put practical things into the bags you won't feel like you wasted money, such as a welcome letter, maybe water/snacks, sunscreen, flip flops, park maps, etc.
I also wrestled with the thought of yes or no but i think im going to do them because its also a nice little project to keep you busy and another element for you to "customize".
I think you're right on the money Shana! That was really helpful input

I think you're so right, there will probably always be at least one person who's unappreciative but I think most people will make use of the bags if I can stick to the contents being practical
I'm very torn on these as well! I know the guests staying where we are getting married will def get their bags... but I worry about what Lurky said about the other place not handing them out....
I'm still trying to even come up with how to make them affordable!
This is what I plan to do as far as handing them out goes: we're going to have a welcome event at my hotel room (we're going to use our DVC points to stay in a 2-bedroom villa) so I will hand out the welcome bags myself there and then. It won't be difficult because they'll all be in my room anyway. Perhaps if you're doing a welcome event or a rehearsal dinner, you could hand them out there yourself if it's not too much trouble? Then you know they'll make it. Otherwise, I think a previous poster mentioned some tricks to ensure they get to your guests on property
To make it affordable, depending on how many guests you're having, I have a couple of ideas: discountmugs.com and printglobe.com have some great stuff and it's really cheap if you're talking price per item, but you have to buy minimum quantities. Sometimes that's 50 sometimes it's as many as 200 depending what item it is. Might work out well if you have a lot of guests. We're not expecting to have that many guests so I'm going to use Oriental Trading for a lot of my stuff because you can buy by the dozen. I hope that wasn't completely useless info!