I will tell you what we did and I LOVED it!!
I registered DH and I for the Spectacle of Lights pin event.
This event was $50 pp and held before the Osbourne Lights was open to the public.
Of course if you are not into pins, you won't care so much for the daytime pin event. But as our event perks paid attendees were allowed on the NYC street, AFTER regular park hours, with a special turning on the lights ceremony. Followed by being able to view and roam around the Osbourne LIghts all we wanted. Under a block long canopy of lights we enjoyed an all you care to eat dessert buffet and beverage bar. Good hot cocoa, cider, coffee, ice cream, cobbler, cookies, etc, beautiful lights, NOT crowded. (Probably limited to 750 guests.) And as a parting gift each attendee received a beautiful 5 pin boxed gift set of Christmas ornament-like pins.
http://www.pinpics.com/cgi-bin/pin.cgi?pin=34728&sid=7277.1110506239.v2
We had a great time and I can't wait to do it again!
Great way to take wonderful photos of that area.
And there are a few roaming characters too. Stitch was there in addition to street performers.
Later we went to see the Osbourne Lights and even on a less crowded night, it was very crowded. The pin event really spoiled us.
Oh yeah!! Each attendee also received a Quick and Casual lunch voucher. We still have ours to use. We took a more leisurely lunch at Prime Time that day as we knew we would not have time for dinner, but would have desserts that evening!