We too arrived at BWV after our cruise and couldn't wait to get into a room. (Cannot believe how tired we were! Or maybe just relaxed, eh?) Since we were checking in on Thanksgiving Day I figured that there wouldn't be many check outs that day; I figured there'd be a room ready and waiting for that long weekend crowd to show up. I was wrong!
We arrived about 11:30 and were told that our room was not ready. They gave us a number to call to check back later. Since we had been at Palos the night before and REALLY scrambled to get our bags out by 11pm, we had no idea where anything in the suitcases was. But the bell hop (and DH) were very kind and searched to find the swimsuits so that we could spend time at the pool. We asked Guest Services if we were able to hop to StormAlong Bay (thinking maybe the crowds were lighter than expected pre-9/11 when they had banned hopping for T-G) and she said sure. I asked her again and asked if she should call over to be certain. She assured me it was no problem and to go enjoy ourselves. Well, after 45 minutes of boat rides around the lagoon, we were back at Luna Park (having been denied access at SAB). But we enjoyed ourselves anyways and made the best of it.
I called at 1:30pm and it still was not ready. The CM said he might be able to get us in another room overlooking the pool, but I asked about the room we were supposed to be in as I had reserved at the 11-month mark. He said he couldn't tell me the room number or location, so I asked, "If it was you, would you wait?" Without hesitation, he said he'd wait, so we did too. DH and the girls swam some more and I fell asleep in a lounge chair. At 2:30 I called again and our room was ready. They sent the bags up, we all went up and were asleep for our "nap" by 3pm. We didn't wake up until 7PM! We then got cleaned up and headed over to ESPN for dinner. I was back in bed by 10pm (I have a really hard time getting my land legs back after cruising) and the rest of the gang in bed AND ASLEEP by 11:15!! WE WERE POOPED!!
I guess the moral of my rambling is that checkin isn't until 4pm and even if you're not prepared for the wait, I don't see how anyone can complain about it. Raising the question so as to brainstorm for ideas for improvement is worthwhile, but of the ideas I've seen so far, I have to disagree with the first-come approach for the same reasons others have stated. The pager idea might be ok, but again, I'm not sure it will reduce the wait time. The current call in system might actually reduce your time as it makes the CMs aware of who is and isn't anxious to get into their rooms. If you are anxious enough to take a lesser view or some other requested preference, the pager system would not alert the CMs to who might be willing to change their request in exchange for getting in sooner.
One possible idea to getting rooms ready sooner actually has to do with checking OUT rather than IN. With express checkout, I always put the SERVICE ROOM tag on the door so that house keeping will know we've left. Other than this, how do they know who's left early to get in one more day of the parks and who is leaving at 11am? Maybe if there was a wake-up call type automated system that you call before leaving, the house keepers could know what rooms they can start on early. What do you think?