OK. I just read all 15 pages of this post - so forgive me if I get any facts messed up here. From reading everyone's past experience, it used to take 10-20 minutes to stand in line and get your food. Now, with the new system at PB's , it took the OP 3-5 minutes. So, those left waiting are waiting 3-5 minutes before they are allowed to be seated. I can completely understand not wanting to wait an extra 10-20 minutes with figity little ones, but 3-5 minutes does not sound unreasonable.
Also, I believe one of the 2 posters who actually experienced this new system said that people with wheelchairs were allowed to enter the dining area prior to having food in hand. So, obviously there are allowances being made for those who need it.
For those concerned about the availability of wheelchair accessible tables, if what the OP says is correct (and I have no reason to doubt him/her at this point) this should greatly increase your ability to find a table that meets your needs. If there are 10-15 tables available at any given time during peak times (I believe this is what the OP reported), and if a CM is directing you to a table, it sounds like the CM is eliminating your run-around. It is up to the CM to locate an appropriate table for you then direct you to it. If they have the musical charis situation worked out, there should be fewer instances of walkways being blocked by people pulling tables together and/or crowding extra chairs around small tables.
Before I get flamed, let me say that I am very curious to see how/if this new systems works out. During my last trip to WDW I was traveling in a party of 5 - including two using
ECV's. One of the ECV users was able to get up and walk for short periods. The other was not (OK, she could hop on her one good leg, but could not effectively/safely transport herself outside of her ECV.) During that trip, the two ECV'ers would find a table while the rest of us got the food. So, we were among the table-savers. On a trip prior to that, we were traveling with my parents and my inlaws. My mom needs to rest often. She never waits in food lines - instead she goes to find a table. All that being said, if the wait for the non-line-standers is only going to be 3-5 minutes, and we are going to have the help of a CM to find an appropriate table, I have to say I am 100% willing to give this new system a chance.
I look forward to hearing more first-hand accounts of this new policy in action.
