In keeping with Kathy's desire to keep us higher on the Resorts forum, I'll update you on the latest from the great Artist Point Disappointment Caper. For those who missed it, our two visits there in 2015 seemed to indicate AP had come out of its three-year funk of inconsistent food and service as both times we had a very good meal, especially last September. Fast forward to 1 Jan, and while the experience wasn't awful, once again the food and service were mediocre which shouldn't be the case when your average entree alone costs $45, much less adding in wine, appetizers/salads, dessert, and coffee. There was a lot of gristle in the buffalo; the sides were plain, boring, and in one case, nearly raw. Service started well but tailed off halfway through the meal to where I'd rate the second half as poor.
We contacted the manager when we returned home (we tend to not make a big issue of meals while dining unless it's absolutely horrific), and we told him of our experience from the standpoint of constructive criticism. He was quite responsive and had one of his area managers call us. We discussed our concerns and mentioned that we were so disappointed that we had cancelled our February ADR. She then asked if we would reconsider and eat with them again on their dime. Honestly, we weren't convinced that we wanted to do so and asked if we could mull over the offer. We did, and yesterday we opted to take them up on their offer (the manager already made the reservation and gave us the confirm #). In the end, it's a gratis meal at the restaurant most sentimental to us which is why we agreed. We're a bit hesitant because a) we're generally not comfortable with getting anything free, especially since we don't want to be seen as complainers; b) we'll expect this meal to be very good which it should be because they're expecting us so is that a fair judge of AP?; and c) if it isn't a good experience, we'll be even more reluctant to come back. Stay tuned!