This is from someone that has been to MVMCP numerous times. Sometimes even twice in the same trip.
This past December, we went on the Tuesday after Thanksgiving (Dec 5th I remember?). This was not a
DVC discount night therefore implying it was suppose to be a busy night anyway. We just couldn't work another night in because of our trip calendar. This was the only night that worked for us.
Clearing the park has become an unadulturated joke. Even some folks I overheard talking said they never buy tickets anymore and that those of us that did were getting ripped off since they got to stay the whole time anyway and just couldn't drink the kool-aid (hot-chocolate). I kinda have to give them their props. They are right. You can't ride attractions anyway for the crowds. It's like EMH on steroids. If you can't ride rides and you don't drink cocoa, why pay the bill? I never saw anybody even close to being
run out.
My wife, DD4 and I love the MK at Christmas. It's why we go. There's something magical about the Christmas parade at night and the snow on MS and holding your 3YODD while watching it all. I can't deny that but it just isn't any fun anymore; at least not for us.
We swore down that we'd never do it again as much as we used to enjoy it. I know we'll break this
vow and probably numerous times since our DD is only 4 now but you get my drift.
I would love for my DD to see MVMCP like it
used to be just one time. But alas, this is true about a lot of things at WDW lately, isn't it?
Some of us had the bar raised too high by Disney years ago. I don't tolerate having my expectations lowered in the name of change very well, I guess. I'm not a very good "go with the flow" kinda guy. My standards are too high. I didn't make'em that way. Disney did. It's why we don't do Six Flags or Universal.
Just my $0.02. YMMV.