First, I respectfully disagree with you, Buschfan. I think
DCL is EXCEPTIONAL for alternatives to the kid's clubs! Have you really been on another cruise line that offers a family night club? Or family game shows? A family casino? Evening programs in the theatre that is G-rated? If so, please let me know which one for our experience has been quite the opposite!
IMO, Disney should not try to offer customized kids programs. I think they are doing a great job of providing both free and structured time. However, parents need to be aware of their children's preferences and schedule their (perhaps brief) adult time accordingly. I would fear that adding additional programming for the same age groups would lead to even MORE decisions for kids to have to make. For those that are happy in either type of activity, they would now need to choose between multiple kids activities on top of the other non-club activities. I think it just becomes more stressful over all. Plus, I liked knowing that I could pull out the Navigator (we also kept it with us at all times) and know where DDs age group was. If there were differing activities, how would you know which one your child was in and where to go to check on them? I hope the changes Matt was talking about was for adding new activities (especially with so many returning kid cruisers) rather than to offer additional concurrent activities.
And as far as Palo's -- that is a totally OPTIONAL event. If your kids don't like the clubs and want to be with you, don't do Palo's. That's simple. We found the other dining choices to be very kid friendly.
As for 8 year olds checking in/out, we, too, were offered that option. It was presented to us more as an exception that they allowed if parents wanted rather than the default which you had to insist your child wasn't allowed to have. Actually, we were surprised they would even allow it. These are ELEMENTARY SCHOOL aged children we're talking about. We definitely declined. Not because DD isn't prepared, but because we know she is only 8 and has ABSOLUTELY no business being unsupervised on a floating city.
As for the pagers, one thing we learned was that they are not really used for custom messages. Ours simply stated that "Your child has requested to be picked up from the Oceaneer's Club" or something to that affect. So, I'm not sure whether they are alpha pagers that can only send generic pre-coded messages, or whether they really could page you with details about where your child was headed once they checked themselves out. Perhaps someone can provide better info about the pagers and how they are used.
For our 4-5 pages, it always said the same thing. And half of those times our DD age 3 only wanted to see us to say she was having fun. She didn't really want to leave at all. But for me it was comforting to know that they would page us whenever DD asked for us. Was it awful timing when we had just entered the Rain Forest Room and had to get dressed to go see what she wanted? Sure, but that's not Disney's fault for 'paging us for every little thing'. She's OUR DD and OUR responsibility -- even on vacation.
Knowing that she was happy whether with us or with the clubs is SO much more important than Palo's chocolate souffle, or the dueling pianos, or the 70's Party at Wave Bands. Were we disappointed that we missed out on some fun due to the dreaded pager? Sure! Would we have it any other way? Not on your life!! JMO.