Turkey tips

My mom has always used the paper bag trick, where you put the turkey in a paper grocery bag. I wouldn't claim to know why it works, but she makes a good turkey! If the turkey is too big, you can use two bags and staple them.
 
The secret with the butter is to rub it under the skin, not on top. We mix poultry seasoning with butter, loosen the skin on the main part of the bird (not wings or bottom of legs) and rub the butter on the meat. Make sure the skin lays back properly, stuff (if you stuff your bird-we do), and bake. Baste frequently using juices and butter drippings in roasting pan (for the first basting, we use a little chicken broth). Use a meat thermometer so you don’t overcook the bird. We have one you can leave in while it bakes.

We always cook a Butterball turkey and they always come out moist and flavorful with an extremely crispy skin.
 

We put bacon strips on top. Don’t know if it helps the turkey, but we love eating it while waiting for turkey to rest.
That’s sounds amazing. I’ve tried that once with beer can chicken. Laying it across the turkey seems like great addition.
 
My mom has always used the paper bag trick, where you put the turkey in a paper grocery bag. I wouldn't claim to know why it works, but she makes a good turkey! If the turkey is too big, you can use two bags and staple them.
My mom always made her roast chicken that way. So delicious. This post made me think of mom and smile.
 
The secret with the butter is to rub it under the skin, not on top. We mix poultry seasoning with butter, loosen the skin on the main part of the bird (not wings or bottom of legs) and rub the butter on the meat. Make sure the skin lays back properly, stuff (if you stuff your bird-we do), and bake. Baste frequently using juices and butter drippings in roasting pan (for the first basting, we use a little chicken broth). Use a meat thermometer so you don’t overcook the bird. We have one you can leave in while it bakes.

We always cook a Butterball turkey and they always come out moist and flavorful with an extremely crispy skin.
I did something similar last year and I messed it up. :(
 
My advice is to not cook a whole turkey.

The dark meat and light meat each need a different temperature for best taste and safety. To get the dark meat to the most flavorful temp you need to either over cook the light meat or jump through a lot of hoops to keep it from being dried out.

If you must cook a whole turkey here are some expert ideas on how to get the temperatures right.

https://blog.thermoworks.com/tips/t...rk meat will will,keep the breast meat tender.)
 
I always brine my turkey, and it always comes out moist and flavorful. It is kind of a pain to do but it works. You just have to make sure you use a turkey that doesn’t already have brine injected. A lot of the name brand ones do.
 
My grandma used mayo, my dad used mayo and I use mayo. Slather it up inside and out, season inside and out really well and put in a paper bag then on a rack in a roasting pan.

Biggest mistakes I see people make:

Not making sure the turkey is 100% thawed. Start thawing your turkey a good 3-5 days out depending on size.

Checking on it constantly, basting and fussing. Every time you open the oven you’re letting all the heat out leading to uneven cooking. Stick a thermometer in it, put it in the oven and leave it alone. If your oven cooks unevenly, turn it once about halfway through.

Overcooking it. Your turkey will continue to cook when it’s resting. Leaving it in the oven until 165 degrees *will* overcook and dry out your turkey. I pull mine around 150-155 and let it come up to temp while resting.

Not letting the turkey rest. Resting is the key to a juicy turkey or any meat. Let it rest for a good 15-20 mins.
 
I always brine my turkey, and it always comes out moist and flavorful. It is kind of a pain to do but it works. You just have to make sure you use a turkey that doesn’t already have brine injected. A lot of the name brand ones do.
I agree with this method. I brine roaster chickens as well throughout the year. Makes an amazing difference.
 
Making a turkey can be as simple or complicated as you make it. Commerical whole frozen turkey are usually injected with a solution (will say on the label) and brining of those is not recommended and can make the turkey excessively salty. Brining involves a lot of extra complication on an already busy cooking holiday, so would just skip that step. Every turkey is a different size, so always use a good meat thermometer to tell when it is done to the correct temperature. You can't reliably tell when a turkey is done by looking or poking it or giggling the legs.

Thawing a whole turkey in the refrigerator can take 3+ days, so make sure to plan ahead.

I melt about 3T of butter to spread over the skin before baking, sprinkle with paprika helps the skin to brown. Put root vegetables (celery/carrots/onion) in the pan to add flavor to the gravy. Chicken or turkey broth/stock can be found in the grocery store and used in place of plain water for added flavor. Place the bird on a rack in your roaster so it isn't sitting in the liquid during baking. Stuffing (if desired) between the skin and white meat insures it cooks completely and helps keep the bird moist. Stuffing the cavity can slow down the cooking process and result in uneven baking. Baste each hour during baking. The dark meat absorbs heat faster than white meat, so the whole bird will be done to the correct temperature even if the various parts register differently. Roasting a whole turkey shouldn't have any issues regarding the temp of the various parts.

Bake at 350. Temperature will rise slowly at first, so don't turn up the oven temperature thinking it isn't going to be done on time. Temperature will rise more quickly toward the end of baking. Check internal temp each time you baste.
 
Making a turkey can be as simple or complicated as you make it. Commerical whole frozen turkey are usually injected with a solution (will say on the label) and brining of those is not recommended and can make the turkey excessively salty. Brining involves a lot of extra complication on an already busy cooking holiday, so would just skip that step. Every turkey is a different size, so always use a good meat thermometer to tell when it is done to the correct temperature. You can't reliably tell when a turkey is done by looking or poking it or giggling the legs.

Thawing a whole turkey in the refrigerator can take 3+ days, so make sure to plan ahead.

I melt about 3T of butter to spread over the skin before baking, sprinkle with paprika helps the skin to brown. Put root vegetables (celery/carrots/onion) in the pan to add flavor to the gravy. Chicken or turkey broth/stock can be found in the grocery store and used in place of plain water for added flavor. Place the bird on a rack in your roaster so it isn't sitting in the liquid during baking. Stuffing (if desired) between the skin and white meat insures it cooks completely and helps keep the bird moist. Stuffing the cavity can slow down the cooking process and result in uneven baking. Baste each hour during baking. The dark meat absorbs heat faster than white meat, so the whole bird will be done to the correct temperature, so you should have no issues roasting the whole turkey.

Bake at 350. Temperature will rise slowly at first, so don't turn up the oven temperature thinking it isn't going to be done on time. Temperature will rise more quickly toward the end of baking. Check internal temp each time you baste.
I avoid any cuts of meat or poultry that has any solution injected. The industry has ruined pork with tenderloins and ribs being saturated with salt. Brining is not that big of a deal. You just need to have a container big enough and prepare ahead. There is also dry brining but I prefer the wet version.
 
I always brine my turkey, and it always comes out moist and flavorful. It is kind of a pain to do but it works. You just have to make sure you use a turkey that doesn’t already have brine injected. A lot of the name brand ones do.
Another frequent “briner” in the house. Butterball, Shady Brook and JennieO, all have fresh and frozen birds without brining solution added but you have to read the labels since it’s more common to find the pre brined versions.

Remember, you need one day of defrosting for every four to five pounds of meat, in the fridge. Don’t be that person who has just started defrosting when your guests are arriving . Yeah, that was me for my first bird 😂

When brining I make sure that the bird spends an equal amt of time air drying in the fridge. This is the prefect time to loosen the breast skin from the meat while it’s still gorged with liquid. Taking the time for this step gives crispier skin and your mouth will thank you.

Don’t have a roasting pan? Just use a sheet pan. A half sheet works for a full sized oven and a quarter sheet for a counter or toaster oven. Forget those finicky turkey tools like the baster. Just use your favorite liquid (beer, stock, water, wine, apple cider etc) in the container of choice (I’m partial to a wine bottle for easy pouring) and pour directly on your cheeseclothed bird. When the cloth starts to dry out add more liquid; easy peasy and less oven temp dropping. Remove the cheese cloth in the last hour for a nice shade of brown.

High spots on the bird browning faster than the rest of the turkey? Use strategic pieces of foil to cover the skin so when finished your meat will basically be evenly browned.
 
Last edited:
I avoid any cuts of meat or poultry that has any solution injected. The industry has ruined pork with tenderloins and ribs being saturated with salt. Brining is not that big of a deal. You just need to have a container big enough and prepare ahead. There is also dry brining but I prefer the wet version.
Industrial brined meat tends to have a mushy texture, IMO😞
 
We don't cook a whole turkey anymore, but IMHO the best way to cook a whole turkey is to spatchcock it:

 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top