Sorry??? I think....
If I'm making you doubt then please don't ask me about my POFQ thoughts and what I would do
Since you have an off day and pool time, I would for sure invest in a stay at AKL. I mean where else in this country can you stay where there are exotic animals roaming just outside? Great food, great pool, beautiful resort .... love it there. Explore all the animal watching locations, the art throughout the resort, great dining!!, often music and entertainment ...
Now POFQ ... has always bothered me that they charge moderate prices yet do not provide a full range of amenities. I don't want to travel to POR for table service or recreation. Now even if I don't use them, I want them there if I'm being charged the same. Now if there were something special there that would be one thing but there's not. So I would always book POR now.
I LOVE NOLA and the French Quarter so the resort visually appealed to me. The rooms are nice and I liked that they used so many different fabrics. But the resort itself was so dead that it felt strange. I'm not happy with the lack of decor in the new food court. It's part of the fun of the resort, and maybe that is because I am aware of where it was made and what it all meant.
My complaints for the pool areas; hot tub is not much bigger than mine at home and down a walkway away from pool and bar. Pool area is highly geared to very young children (mine at 9 has zero interest) and therefore there are lots of kids there. The pool decks were expanses of concrete with virtually no shade. Nothing was special about the theme at the pool, same as any club pool.
Compared to AKL which the pool deck is curvy with hidden spots, lush landscape, shaded areas, two hidden away hot tubs, bridges, animals, right next to food court, bar, nice bathrooms. It's truly a beautiful and creative watering hole for humans.
POFQ
From PortOrleans.org
See lots of open pool deck, like a swim club
AKL
Disney Tourist Blog photo
Davids Vacation Club photo
From Disboards poster