I am not really a fan of Adventures By Disney or any tour. Basically you wind up spending your entire time in Europe with AMERICANS! So... where's the cultural learning there? Don't we already know how Americans work? And actually having watched an Adventures by Disney from a distance (the London tour was staying in my hotel last Christmas) yes it's nice, but it's way overpriced and boy are you protected. Meeting a real Brit who wasn't being paid by Disney would have been VERY hard LOL! And I did basically the same things for a lot less money. (Except that I went to see Wicked instead of Mary Poppins.)
I think that many of you know my opinion of ABD and Rick Steves. I too have encountered the ABD crowds and I must say that I was very disappointed by what I saw. The Germany intinerary I find very cliched. I will leave it at that as I was pretty much driven off with pitchforks by some rather strong ABD fans.
Carol and I disagree about Rick Steves; I know that he has made Europe 'easy' to many Americans but I have seen so many places become Americanized thanks to Rick. I was walking past a restaurant in Vatican City this summer, crowded with Americans, which advertised proudly 'recommended by Rick Steves'. The problem is that his name attracts so many Americans that they sometimes lose some of their charm and local flavour. I do find his radio show in particular patronizing to both Americans as well as Europeans; some say that his books can be similar but I know that he has fans.
But I do applaud the fact that he has helped people to move outside their comfort zone, and if it means doing things differently that I would, so be it.
For me I would not do a tour; I spent this summer in Europe in popular tourist destinations including Nice, Monaco, Paris, Bavaria, Salzburg, Rome, etc and I encountered many groups. Finding one which meets your personality seems to be key, but I would also wonder how much of the
true local experience one can have. I used to walk to work in Vatican City and smile inwardly at the tour escorts shouting and hurrying their charges along in the 35 degree heat. Nobody seemed to be enjoying themselves, sadly.
I've also seen tour groups literally racing through Versailles and other tourist sites in Paris. That is not my way to see something new, but if it appeals due to the 'safety' factor then go ahead. Everyone is different.
Many people PM me for advice about travel in Germany/Austria/France and I am always delighted to assist. Many posters here are quite adventurous and interested in going off the beaten path.
It comes down to your priority - tours are not cheap, and you can explore Europe still very cheaply on your own, with just a little sound research. The Euro plummeted from a high of 1,54 in August to 1,25 now, so even better.