Did you at least get your money back? He does offer the money back guarantee...so, you shouldn't worry about wasting money. If you don't like it, you will get your money back.
I agree with the positive posters. We visited WDW in 2004 for the 1st time in about 10 years. I had purchased the Unofficial Guide for that trip. I didn't use any of the touring plans...and boy was that a long trip. Long lines, cranky child, etc. We didn't get as much done as I thought we could have.
Last year, we returned again in June. I used the TGM BEST DAYS to plan out our trip and it was great. No long lines, and everything went smoothly.
We are going back again this June and I subscribed again. I re-read the Unofficial Guide and found the touring plans to be a little too "commando" for me.....but, it does have excellent information that can be used to put together your own touring plan.
My advice would be to definitely try TGM or get The Unofficial Guide and take their advice on which parks to go to on which days as well as which rides to hit early in the day to avoid lines. Many people have talked about being able to get the Unofficial Guide from their local library. That may be an option to help you save money as well.
Speed