Torn about what to do about dining plan...

katymare

Earning My Ears
Joined
Aug 13, 2008
Messages
42
:confused: Can anyone give me an idea of cost savings? (is that even possible) :) There are 4 of us going..me and my husband, my 10yr old son and my 3 yr old daughter. She is not a big eater and my son may mor may not eat a lot....we tend to carry in snacks in mybackpack. I am all about savings. We are going to be at Disney for 8 days and have reservations almost everyday at a sit down restaurant. Just not sure what to do.:confused3

any advice would be appreciated!!!!:goodvibes
 
You have to look at menus and compare what you'd normally eat without the dining plan- add up those costs (don't forget tax, and tips for table service...and the drinks at $2 each!) and see what your dining plan cost would be comparatively. Don't forget to add to the dining plan cost those things you would eat that aren't included on the plan, if any. And that just determines if its a good value money wise. It could be that its a better value cost wise, but would be too much of a departure from how you prefer to eat. Or like in another thread, perhaps you're vegetarians who don't like soft drinks- which could really make the DDP more costly than dining OOP.

I'm on the edge about 2009- we're coming out about even, but the dining plan would provide more food. We would eat at different places on the dining plan vs. OOP (less expensive places on our own, but ones that we love...forgoing more expensive places we also like...) and I'm really very much an appetizer and dessert person....skip the entree... so that would be different. I think for the first time I might prefer to go it on our own, but we may do the dining plan because its a little less costly. Also I have the issue of having used the DDP the last few visits, so its almost an expectation of my teenager to be able to order whatever he wants. I like giving him that freedom without worrying about the budget.

IF you usually eat at a table service restaurant (but NOT the 2 credit places) and a counter service restaurant every day, in most cases I think you'd come out ahead with DDP. If you like more expensive entrees, or even buffets (particularly if you have kids age 3-9) you'll likely still come out ahead even if you usually pack your lunch. So then you don't have to bring lunch! I've found in most cases the DDP (even 2009's) is a good value, though not as huge a savings as it was in the past. So if you really don't want to crunch the numbers and you're not particularly light eaters (or vegetarian) and you're willing to work within the plan's parameters....it's probably at least a small savings.
 
:confused: We are going to be at Disney for 8 days and have reservations almost everyday at a sit down restaurant. Just not sure what to do.

Your indication that you carry food to eat and that your kids don't eat a lot would normally suggest you don't need the DP. However, the fact that you will be paying for a TS just about every night and you are going when holiday premium pricing is in effect suggests that this time the DP might be a good deal for you, esp. if those meals are buffet/character.

You should do your own math:
Add up cost of everything you're likely to order w/o the DP. TS, CS and snacks.
Multiply that number by 1.065 to get a total including tax.
Do this for each day and add up the daily totals.

Your DP has 3A and 1C so since your trip is in 2008 the nightly fee for the DP is $124 including taxes. That is a 7 night total of $868.

For your TS meals that are character or buffet there will be a Holiday Premium that should total $14 each time at those meals. For example if you choose to have dinner at Chef Mickey's it will cost you: $33.99 per Adult and $16.99 for your 3yo. Without the DP that meal would cost you $127, more than the DP for that day and under the DP you could still get 3A CS meals, a Child CS meal and 4 snacks that day, easily worth $50, consider that your savings that day.

However, if you choose to have lunch at Sci Fi while at the DHS your bill could look more like: $54 assuming both your kids got kids meals, you had 2 milkshakes and one flavored soda and no desserts or appetizers were ordered. I also assumed the least expensive entrees on the menu for the adults. To breakeven on that day your CS meals and snacks would need to add up to $70. However, if you add up the two days together the total be close to $180 or $90 per night just for your TS meals. If it would cost you around $35 a day for snacks and CS meals then you don't need the plan. For many families it would cost more than that.

The key really is to go day by day and price out what you're likely to spend $ on for meals, drinks and snacks. If you can feed your family for under your DP fee amount (be realistic with what you'd order/buy) then don't get the plan and sleep well knowing that decision was right for your family. Keep in mind that if you order appetizers or alcoholic drinks you will still have to pay for those as they are not included on the basic DP. I'm not sure if there will be amazing savings for you and Disney isn't planning of that, but some savings and feeding your family comfortably are possible on the plan.

From Allears.net:

Recently, Walt Disney World began charging a premium on certain meals and dining experiences during peak seasons. Such seasonal pricing will be implemented at the following dining locations during peak seasons:

-- 1900 Park Fare
-- Akershus
-- Biergarten
-- Boma
-- Cape May Cafe
-- Chef Mickey's
-- Cinderella's Royal Table
-- Crystal Palace
-- Garden Grill
-- Hollywood and Vine
-- Liberty Tree Tavern (dinner only)
-- 'Ohana
-- Trails End
-- Tusker House

Upcoming peak times that will see the seasonal price increases are:
December 16, 2008 - January 3, 2009

Other date were listed, but this confirm the Holiday pricing for your trip.
 
:confused: Can anyone give me an idea of cost savings? (is that even possible) :) There are 4 of us going..me and my husband, my 10yr old son and my 3 yr old daughter. She is not a big eater and my son may mor may not eat a lot....we tend to carry in snacks in mybackpack. I am all about savings. We are going to be at Disney for 8 days and have reservations almost everyday at a sit down restaurant. Just not sure what to do.:confused3

any advice would be appreciated!!!!:goodvibes

that you can fill in your anticipated meals and it lets you know if it's worth it for you or not. Maybe someone here can help you our and post a link to it.

I have no idea where I found it, but I had alot of fun playing around with it!

Karen
 

I have a copy of that spreadsheet and will email it to you. I'm not sure if you have enough posts to send a Private Message (click on my name to the left and choose to send a private message). If you don't, post back here and I'll PM you my email address, so you can drop me a note and I can send you the spreadsheet.

It's on a public domain somewhere, but I don't have that link saved.
 
:confused: Can anyone give me an idea of cost savings? (is that even possible) :) There are 4 of us going..me and my husband, my 10yr old son and my 3 yr old daughter. She is not a big eater and my son may mor may not eat a lot....we tend to carry in snacks in mybackpack. I am all about savings. We are going to be at Disney for 8 days and have reservations almost everyday at a sit down restaurant. Just not sure what to do.:confused3

any advice would be appreciated!!!!:goodvibes



We did the dining plan last time we went, and we saved a fortune. Now, it is different, but we are still doing it despite the fact that we arn't saving as much. The cost of the kids is paid for with one buffet or charater meal a day which it sounds like you are doing. It was fun to be able to tell the kids YES to treats and desserts, which normally we'd pull somehting out of our bag like you. Really it enhanced our vacation. Did we need the extras, no. But it made it really fun and that is why we like to do it.
 
Don't forget your ten year old will be considered an adult on the ddp. If he still wants mac and cheese or chicken nuggets you may lose a lot on the ddp. Then again this makes no difference at buffets where he'll have to pay adult price anyway, so where you want to eat will be very important.
 
I have a copy of that spreadsheet and will email it to you. I'm not sure if you have enough posts to send a Private Message (click on my name to the left and choose to send a private message). If you don't, post back here and I'll PM you my email address, so you can drop me a note and I can send you the spreadsheet.

It's on a public domain somewhere, but I don't have that link saved.

I dont think Im able to PM yet but would be interested in this spreadsheet :) :surfweb:
 
I did a compare btw what we realistically would order based on our dining habits and the DXDP (we planned on doing many signatures) and we will do better with the DDE card than DXDP. It also better suits our touring style

We like to split an appy, not one each
We do not order dessert at every dinner
We usually split one dessert occassionally
We do not buy many snacks

It is as much about how you like to tour as well as if you would save money.

It is hard work planning a Disney vacation isn't it? It is harder too that your son would pay adult prices but may still have the preferences of the child's menu
 
We're going over Christmas with two small children, 2 and 10 months. We are doing a total of 7 character meals: Tusker House
Liberty Tree Tavern
Chef Mickeys
Hollywood and Dine
O'hana's for breakfast
Crystal Palace
Garden Grill (dinner)
and Christmas at the Fort

Between these and the rest of our meals we figure we will save about $300 vs out of pocket. Also the kidlets are still free and with the deluxe plan we will have LOTS of food to share with them! Also 6 snacks a day!
So for this trip it will turn out the best for us to go deluxe.
 
Darling Daughter (who will be six by then) and I are going to WDW in October... Our reservations are:

1900 Park Fare (D) Grand Floridian [Day 1]
Ohana's (B) Polynesian [Day 2]
Cinderella's Royal Table (D) Magic Kingdom [Day 2]
Chef Mickey's (D) Contemporary [Day 3]
Hoop Dee Doo Review (D) Fort Wilderness [Day 4]
Akershus - Princess Storybook Breakfast (B) EPCOT [Day 5]
Garden Grill (D) EPCOT [Day 5]
Donald's Safari Breakfast (B) Animal Kingdom [Day 6]

That still leaves us with 10 credits to use up. Any suggestions for a few more meals?

Day One is MK, Day Two is MK, Day Three is MK, Day Four is HS, Day Five is EP and Day Six is AK. No Hopper or Water Park.
 
Darling Daughter (who will be six by then) and I are going to WDW in October... Our reservations are:

1900 Park Fare (D) Grand Floridian [Day 1] Early lunch at the Plaza or Main Street Bakery
Ohana's (B) Polynesian [Day 2]
Cinderella's Royal Table (D) Magic Kingdom [Day 2]
Chef Mickey's (D) Contemporary [Day 3] Grand Floridian Cafe or Crystal Palace breakfast
Hoop Dee Doo Review (D) Fort Wilderness [Day 4] H&V Character Bfast
Akershus - Princess Storybook Breakfast (B) EPCOT [Day 5] Coral Reef Lunch
Garden Grill (D) EPCOT [Day 5]
Donald's Safari Breakfast (B) Animal Kingdom [Day 6] Dinner at Boma

That still leaves us with 10 credits to use up. Any suggestions for a few more meals?

Day One is MK, Day Two is MK, Day Three is MK, Day Four is HS, Day Five is EP and Day Six is AK. No Hopper or Water Park.

Not sure eating 3 meals at Epcot would work, but I'd suggest Coral Reef over Garden Grill. You have lots of character meals and Coral Reef is unique; our 6yo loved it and we all loved the food. Its a Lunch or Dinner option and can be a difficult ADR.

I wouldn't hesitate to use your CS credits freely for small meals back at the resort or any in between times as well.
 
Don't forget your ten year old will be considered an adult on the ddp. If he still wants mac and cheese or chicken nuggets you may lose a lot on the ddp. Then again this makes no difference at buffets where he'll have to pay adult price anyway, so where you want to eat will be very important.
This is now a dillema for me as well :confused: My ds is now 10, and I am really going to have to sit down and figure out if the ddp is going to be worth it :confused: He can consume a lot of food, but he probably won't like the selections on the adult menu's at a lot of the restaurants
:headache:
 
Thank you all for this great advice....my husband and I are looking at all options..we appreciate all the help!!
 
For us it was a matter of not having to stress about cost. My DH, love him so much, but man is he, ahem, frugal. So it helps a lot to not have to pay for meals. Especially since we did character dining and CRT. No way would he have agreed to do that given the cost if we were paying OOP. So even though we wouldn't necessarily all get a dessert every meal or whatever, it was worth it to not have to worry about the money. This year will be a little harder given the whole tip thing, but it'll still be WAY better than having him gripe about the cost of every single meal :lol:
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom