Tony's Town Square OR Plaza??

[hooch11bear]

We have eaten at Tony's several times, and I have always stuck up for it. However, on our last trip we had the same server we had the previous year, and he is awful. I'm not sure why he even has a job there. I never complain about service. I am pretty easy going as far as that goes. He wasn't friendly, rushed us through our meal, never refilled our drinks and has left me with a sour taste in my mouth. I don't have any complaints about our service at any other restaurant, and I typically make around 24 reservations during our 2 weeks on property. The food is not that great. To be honest, the only reason it was on my list of places to eat was becasue of the pistachio creme brulee. I am not planning on going back any time soon!! We are trying The Plaza for the first time this year. It seems to get pretty good reviews.

 

[wintotty]

Oh wow, thank you everyone....I didn't even know Tony's got tons of negative review. Last 2 times we were there, we didn't have any dinner ADR and had my husband rush for some counter service meal, so I thought we should try a table dinner before the parade and wish, and those 2 restaurants to be close proximity for both event after eating. I guess I'll keep the Plaza ADR for now and decide if I should keep that, or go for Dessert Party (then we'll miss the parade though.....)

 

[VillianDiva]

Definitely Plaza! Tony's hasn't been good the last two times I've been there.

 

[sjs314]

I was going back and forth between The Plaza And Tony's too. I finally chose The Plaza even though I have never ate there as the menu just appealed to me more, plus I hear the milkshakes and ice cream are great!

Tony's is ok but there are better places to eat Italian, just not in MK.

 

[sabcook]

Another vote for the Plaza. I would skip the dessert party, watch the parade up close and then get something scrumptious from the bakery .

 

[pmaurer74]

we did not like Tony's. I prefer the Plaza or Liberty Tree. We are doing the Wishes party for the first time this year.