Tony's in MK...is it really bad?

[markb681]

Chef Boyardee quality...and YES I'm very serious!

 

[MichelleWDWfan]

I have enjoyed a few meals at Tony's.
The decor is nice and I've never had a bad server.

Best time to go in my opinion is when they first open for lunch
My favorite entrees are the Shrimp scampi, and the Cannelloni
Bread service is good as well.

I ate there in March and the Cannelloni wasn't on the menu, so I got the NY strip steak instead.

 

[ScubaCat]

Yeah, it's really, really bad. Eat at Olive Garden on your way in for a far superior experience.

No joke. Out last time there was indescribably horrendous.

 

[Minniemoo15]

It wasn't bad - we booked the festival of fantasy FP package so it was actually a great value. The food wasn't incredible so we likely won't be back, but I'm glad we tried it and certainly didn't leave disappointed or anything

 

[Chae]

I've eaten there a few times and always been happy- the last time was in February and it was good! That being said I don't care for Tutto Italia at all! Once again- to each his own!

 

[soonerdog]

It wasn't horrible, but it wasn't fantastic. Like a lot of others, I'd compare it to the Olive garden. It was lovely to look at, we had good service, and my daughters loved the lady and the tramp theming. I just needed AC to get out of the August heat for a while though, so in that way it was incredible!

 

[Mambo Junkie]

Last September, we did the MSEP package at Tonys. It was one of the best things we did on our trip! We had great service, good food and a great view of the castle, Wishes and MSEP from the front of the hub! I would do it again. I liked my dinner. When I asked DH he said, "Pretty good". Most of the time he says, "It's ok", even if he liked it. Anything above that means he really liked it. The only other response is if he "didn't care for it" or a very rare, "it was really good".

 

[DVC_Dad_Canada]

For the money you are paying for the food, it should be infinitely better. There are so many better options for the money withing 15 minutes of Tony's at the same price point. Add the monorail resorts and there are even more.

Personally, for table service, Skipper Canteen is my favourite at MK. Unless you MUST have italian at MK, I'd choose other italian restaurants.

 

[RescueRanger]

Chef Boyardee quality...and YES I'm very serious!

Chef Boyardee is going to sue you for slander. Yuk! Tony's is awful. And to the person who said that it was better than Tutto, well I just don't know what to say.

 

[MichelleWDWfan]

Honestly it's all personal opinion. Not everyone likes everything.
The reviews here are mixed. Some of us like Tony's and other's don't.
If you have never eaten at Tony's at least give it a shot once and see what you think.

 

[Uncranky Donald]

I have been ritually going to Tony's since I was a child. Last time I went in 2014 I found pieces of iceberg lettuce and a corner of an industrial plastic kitchen bag in my Cioppino (I don't think they were supposed to be in the recipe) The waiter was kind of rude and rushed us...my tummy didn't have nice things to say about dinner later either
However, my uncle thought his Chicken Parm was amazing and I have previously had several amazing meals there many years earlier. I have given up Tony's for now, but I would never tell someone else to judge an entire place based on any one experience, besides, I still love the atmosphere and location as that's why we ever really went there to begin with If it's calling your name, give it a try, especially if your expectations are low then there's a great chance they'll be exceeded

 

[qwerty2k]

It's kinda meh for me. By no means terrible and I wouldn't say I would never eat there again...it would just never be a choice that sprang to mind.

 

[jeffbear]

I won't give it a blanket label, but I will say that I honestly do not enjoy Tony's anywhere near as much as literally every other table service restaurant in MK ... and several of the counter service experiences. Speaking only of food. I really like the decor.