I hate to hear anything negative about Disney. I will defend it to the death if need be.
That said, I must confess...
I was also a single woman with a teen on the 11/28 Wonder cruise. My DD is 16, and was in CG the night in question. She described to me in detail about how they were playing a game, and kids were saying something inappropriate, and a parent walked in. She told me the exact same thing as Toadman's DD said. The counselor immediately said, "Who is your favorite Disney Character". This must have been discussed previously because all teens knew what it meant. I was not happy, but I wasn't blown away either. Of course, my child is older...
She did not tell me anything about smoking, but since that is a HUGE issue in our house, you can bet she wouldn't. She knows that I would have flipped!!!!
I NEVER get involved in these kind of discussions. I hate the controversy, and all the conflict. I would love to just sit by and pretend I knew nothing. I also hate to watch somebody get bashed, when I know for a fact that they are right.
I must add this tho...the only part I am defending here is that the event in question DID take place. I am not taking sides, I just wanted to add some corroboration.
Now...all that said...
I will definitely take another
Disney cruise, and I will Definitely allow my DD to go back to CG, and I would definitely recommend it to others, as is, no changes to rules or CM's.